A software company is launching a new analytics add-on for its existing customers. How would you set the price?

Price on the value the add-on creates, not its cost. Estimate what customers save or earn from the analytics, compare that with their alternatives, including doing nothing, and charge a share of it. Segment by customer size, pick a charging model and test before rollout.

Updated

How a 90-point answer starts

Before I pick a method, what's the goal for this add-on? Is it meant to grow revenue per customer, or mainly to keep customers from leaving?

See the full answer, the 50 and 70 versions, and what moves each score up.

Practice this question free

The numbers, step by step

Take a customer with 10 seats at $100 a seat a month, where the add-on saves ten hours of analyst time a month at $50 an hour.

Value of the time saved10 hours × $50
$500 a month
Add-on at 20% of the seat price$100 × 20% × 10 seats
$200 a month
Add-on at 30% of the seat price$100 × 30% × 10 seats
$300 a month
Share of the value taken at 20%$200 ÷ $500
40%
Share of the value taken at 30%$300 ÷ $500
60%

What the interviewer listens for

  • Do you ask what the add-on is meant to achieve before pricing it?
  • Do you lead with value to the customer and treat cost as a floor?
  • Do you think about how to charge as well as how much?
  • Do you land on a recommendation you would test?

Common mistakes

  • Building the price up from cost.One more customer costs almost nothing to serve, so cost is a floor and says nothing about the right number.
  • The competitor is often doing nothing.For an add-on, the customer's alternative is a spreadsheet and some analyst hours, and that's the price to beat.
  • One price for everyone.A 10-seat customer and an enterprise account get very different value from the same dashboard, so segment first and name numbers after.
  • A price that annoys the base fails the brief, however well the add-on sells.

Likely follow-ups

  • The add-on saves a 10-seat customer $500 a month. At 30% of a $100 seat, what share of that value do you take?Ten seats at $30 is $300 a month, so 60%. That's a lot to ask for a new product, and I'd test the 20% price too, which takes 40%.
  • What happens with per-seat pricing for a 200-seat customer?They'd pay $6,000 a month at $30 a seat, likely more than the analytics are worth to them. If value doesn't grow with seats, which I'd check, I'd cap it or use flat tiers for big accounts.
  • Why not give it free to enterprise customers to protect renewals?Only inside a higher tier that costs more. Giving it away teaches customers it's worth nothing, which makes charging for it later much harder.
“My biggest issue was waiting for the interviewer to tell me what to do next. The Soreno cases got me used to suggesting a direction.”
Nathan P.BCG associate offer

More case openings

Case interview questionsAll interview questionsFree sample casesPricing case practiceCase interview prep plan

Ready for an interviewer that talks back?

Start the 7-day free trial and run your first full case with the AI interviewer today.

Start your free week