A carmaker is deciding whether to keep making a key component in-house or buy it from a supplier. How would you approach it?

Ask why the question is coming up now and how strategic the component is. Compare the supplier's price with the in-house costs that would actually stop, not allocated overhead. Then weigh quality, supply risk, lock-in and what happens to the plant and workers.

Updated

How a 90-point answer starts

Two questions first. What's prompting this now, a supplier's offer or an investment the plant needs?

See the full answer, the 50 and 70 versions, and what moves each score up.

Practice this question free

The numbers, step by step

An invented split of a $2,000 unit cost at 250,000 transmissions a year, against a supplier quote of $1,800, which is 10% below it.

Saving a year as quoted250,000 × ($2,000 − $1,800)
$50 million
Costs that stop if they buy, people included$1,300 materials + $500 labor + $50 overhead
$1,850 a unit
Costs that stay$100 overhead + $50 depreciation
$150 a unit
Cost of buying per unit$1,800 quote + $30 freight and inspection
$1,830
Running saving per unit$1,850 − $1,830
$20
Running saving a year250,000 × $20
$5 million

What the interviewer listens for

  • Do you ask why the question has come up now?
  • Do you compare the supplier's price with the costs that would stop, not the full unit cost?
  • Do you ask whether the part is something the carmaker should own?
  • Do you cover supply and quality risk, including being locked in later?
  • Do you say what happens to the freed plant, equipment and people?

Common mistakes

  • Comparing the supplier's quote with the full in-house unit cost.Plant overhead mostly stays and depreciation on existing machines is sunk, so the true saving is far smaller.
  • Cost isn't the whole case.A part that makes the car different, or that matters for future models, can be worth making even when buying is cheaper.
  • Severance and an empty building are costs of buying, and a better use of the space is a benefit, so count the people and the plant.
  • The first quote won't last.Once the in-house line closes the carmaker can't easily return, and the supplier knows it at the next negotiation.

Likely follow-ups

  • If the new equipment would last eight years, what does buying avoid each year?About $25 million a year, five times the $5 million running saving, so the case for buying rests mostly on not spending the $200 million.
  • The supplier's price is fixed for three years. What would you put in the contract?Pricing for the model's whole life, tied to material costs, with volume bands, quality penalties and audit rights. Plus a second qualified source, so one failure can't stop the line.
  • Does the move to electric cars push toward buying?Yes, if this transmission is fading out. $200 million on equipment for a part with a shrinking future is hard to justify, and the plant's skills could go into electric drive units.
“I liked being asked what the number actually meant for the client. That was probably the most useful part of the case practice.”
Lucas H.McKinsey offer

More case openings

Case interview questionsAll interview questionsFree sample casesOperations case practiceCase interview prep plan

Ready for an interviewer that talks back?

Start the 7-day free trial and run your first full case with the AI interviewer today.

Start your free week