An airline's profits are falling even though it is carrying more passengers. What is going on?

More passengers can still mean less profit if fares or costs moved the wrong way. Compare revenue per seat mile with cost per seat mile. Check whether growth came from fare cuts or cheaper leisure routes, then whether fuel and labor costs rose faster.

Updated

How a 90-point answer starts

Let me check two things. What period are we looking at, and is revenue up along with passengers?

See the full answer, the 50 and 70 versions, and what moves each score up.

Practice this question free

The numbers, step by step

Seat miles grow from 10 to 11.2 billion, revenue per seat mile falls from 14 to 13 cents and cost per seat mile creeps from 12 to 12.2 cents.

Profit before10 billion × (14 − 12) cents
$200 million
Revenue after11.2 billion × 13 cents
$1.456 billion
Revenue growth$1.456 billion ÷ $1.4 billion − 1
4%
Cost after11.2 billion × 12.2 cents
$1.366 billion
Profit after$1.456 billion − $1.366 billion
about $90 million

What the interviewer listens for

  • Do you use the clue that passengers are up while profit is down?
  • Do you think per passenger or per seat, and not in totals?
  • Do you separate industry-wide pressures from this airline's own choices?
  • Do you offer a hypothesis for how growth could destroy profit?

Common mistakes

  • More passengers can mean less revenue per seat.If the extra seats were filled with cheap fares, revenue per seat mile falls while the planes look full.
  • Profit per passenger can't compare a short hop with a long flight, which is why airlines measure per seat mile.
  • Blaming fuel without checking rivals.Fuel and pilot pay hit every airline, so if rivals' margins held, the problem is this airline's.
  • Counting passengers, not what they paid.Swap a few business travelers for leisure ones and revenue can drop sharply while the count goes up.

Likely follow-ups

  • Revenue per seat mile fell from 14 to 13 cents while cost rose from 12 to 12.2. What happened to the margin?It fell from 2 cents to 0.8, a 60% drop. Even with 12% more seat miles, profit goes from $200 million to about $90 million.
  • Profit by route shows the new routes losing money and the old ones fine. What do you recommend?Give each new route a deadline to reach a target fare and load, and move the planes from those that miss.
  • Rivals' margins held up over the same years. What does that tell you?That fuel and the market aren't the main story. I'd compare our fare and cost per seat mile with theirs route by route, starting with the new routes.
“The case feedback picked up something my friends hadn't mentioned: I was doing the maths without explaining why. That was useful to catch.”
Owen D.Bain offer

More case openings

Case interview questionsAll interview questionsFree sample casesProfitability case practiceCase interview prep plan

Ready for an interviewer that talks back?

Start the 7-day free trial and run your first full case with the AI interviewer today.

Start your free week