Tell me about a time you had to work closely with someone who saw a problem very differently from you.

Choose a disagreement where you each had part of the answer. Show you studied their evidence before pushing your view, then settled it with a test or data you both trusted. Close on the business result and how you work together now.

Updated

How a 90-point answer starts

I was the operations lead at a 30-person software startup, and we were losing about 4% of our customers every month. Our head of sales, Daniel, was sure the problem was price.

See the full answer, the 50 and 70 versions, and what moves each score up.

Practice this question free

Structure it with the STAR method template

What the interviewer listens for

  • Do you describe the other person fairly?
  • Did you try to understand their view before pushing yours?
  • Did the relationship survive the disagreement?
  • What did you learn from being partly wrong?

Common mistakes

  • The other person comes across as a fool.If they had no good reason for their view, the story turns into one about your patience. Give their best argument in terms they'd accept.
  • Winning the argument and calling it collaboration.The question is whether you could work beside a client who disagrees, and a story with a loser doesn't answer that.
  • You were right about everything.Pick another story, because admitting what they saw that you missed makes your side believable.
  • Nobody tested anything.Two opinions and a meeting aren't a resolution, so say what data or trial settled it and that you both agreed beforehand to go with the result.

Likely follow-ups

  • What if the test had gone their way?Say you'd have backed their plan fully, and name what you'd still keep an eye on, like the one number that worried you most.
  • How do the two of you work together now?Give one thing that shows it, like them adopting part of your approach or asking your view on a later decision.
  • At what point do you stop trying to agree and escalate?Once a deadline forces a call and you've both made your case on the facts, go up together with both views on one page.
“I liked having feedback while the case was still fresh. I'd usually try another one straight after.”
Elliot M.McKinsey offer

More behavioral and fit

Consulting behavioral interview questionsAll interview questionsBehavioral interview practiceTimed video practiceHireVue interview questionsMcKinsey PEI questions

Ready for an interviewer that talks back?

Start the 7-day free trial and answer your first question out loud to the AI interviewer today.

Start your free week