Tell me about a time you went above and beyond.
Pick a time you did more than asked after finishing your own work. Explain what you noticed, why it mattered to the client or team, and how you got your manager on board. End with a measurable result someone else noticed.
See this answer go from 50 to 90
Example answer
50/100
Last summer I was a finance intern at a regional furniture retailer with 40 stores. Every Monday I updated the weekly sales report and sent it to the store managers.
I always tried to do more than I was asked. I stayed late most nights and took on extra tasks. In my third week I noticed that delivery refunds looked high at some stores, and I told my manager.
She said I was one of the hardest-working interns they'd had. What I took from it is that going beyond the job gets noticed.
What holds it back
Staying late and taking extra tasks are effort, and every candidate claims them. The refund finding is the real story, but it gets one sentence and stops at telling the manager.
Last summer I was a finance intern at a regional furniture retailer with 40 stores. My assignment was narrow. Every Monday I updated the weekly sales report and sent it to the store managers. In my third week I noticed that delivery refunds looked high at some stores. Nobody had asked me to look at refunds, and I could have just sent the report. I decided to find out why. I told my manager first, and she agreed as long as the report still went out on time. I stayed late for two weeks and went through the refund records. Most of them were for late deliveries, and those stores all used the same delivery contractor. I wrote up what I found and shared it with the operations manager. He moved some of the stores to a second contractor. By the end of my internship, refunds at those stores had come down a lot. What I took from it is that going beyond the job only counts if the job itself still gets done.
Last summer I was a finance intern at a regional furniture retailer with 40 stores. My assignment was narrow. Every Monday I updated the weekly sales report and sent it to the store managers. In my third week I noticed that delivery refunds looked high at six stores, about three times the rate of the others. Nobody had asked me to look at refunds, and I could have just sent the report. I decided to find out why, because refunds sat between finance and operations and neither team owned them. I told my manager first, and she agreed as long as the report still went out on time. I stayed late for two weeks and went through 1,200 refund records by hand. Most of them were for late deliveries, and those stores all used the same delivery contractor, which was missing its delivery window on about one order in five. I wrote up what I found on one page and asked the operations manager for 15 minutes. I'd expected him to be defensive, so I brought the order numbers and no opinion about the contractor. He moved four of the six stores to a second contractor as a test. By the end of my internship, late-delivery refunds at those four stores had fallen from about $18,000 a month to about $7,000. The finance director added the refund breakdown to the weekly report, and I wrote down the steps so the next intern could run it. What I took from it is that going beyond the job only counts if the job itself still gets done and someone can act on what you found.
Structure it with the STAR method template
What the interviewer listens for
- Was this beyond what you were asked to do, or just your job done well?
- What was the moment you chose to do more, and why?
- Did your normal work still get done?
- What changed because of it, and can you measure it?
Common mistakes
- Offering long hours as the story.Staying late shows effort, but it doesn't show a choice you made or a result anyone else could see.
- Telling a story where the extra work was assigned by a manager, which is a bigger workload and not initiative.
- Going around your manager to look good, or letting your real assignment slip while you chased the extra project.
- Ending on praise you received, like a thank-you email, when the interviewer wants to know what changed for the business.
More behavioral and fit
- Tell me about a difficult problem you solved.
- Tell me about a time you had to learn something new quickly.
- Tell me about a time you had to work without clear direction.
- Describe a time the numbers and the stories you were hearing did not match. What did you do?
- Tell me about a time you achieved something difficult against real obstacles.
Investment banking fit questionsAll interview questionsBehavioral interview practiceTimed video practiceHireVue interview questionsMcKinsey PEI questions
Ready for an interviewer that talks back?
Start the 7-day free trial and run your first full case with the AI interviewer today.
Start 7-day free trial