Tell me about a time you disagreed with your manager.
The disagreement should matter, and you should have raised it privately with evidence. Show you understood your manager's reasoning, said what you saw differently and stayed open to being wrong. Then give the outcome, whoever was right, and how the relationship held.
Updated
How a 90-point answer starts
Last summer I interned on the pricing team at a regional grocery chain with about 60 stores. My manager, Tom, had me analyze a test where 10 stores cut prices on store-brand basics.
See the full answer, the 50 and 70 versions, and what moves each score up.
Practice this question freeStructure it with the STAR method template
What the interviewer listens for
- Was it a real disagreement about something that mattered?
- Did you raise it directly, privately and with evidence?
- Can you give your manager's side fairly?
- Would this manager want to work with you again?
Common mistakes
- The manager was simply wrong and you were simply right.The interviewer starts to wonder how you'd describe them a year from now.
- Describing a disagreement you never voiced.Quietly doing it your own way, or complaining to a peer, is the behavior the question is designed to catch.
- The conversation itself is missing."I told him what I thought" leaves out the sentence you said, and that sentence is the evidence.
- Picking something trivial, like a font or a meeting time.It suggests you've never disagreed about anything that carried risk.
Likely follow-ups
- Your manager hears you out and overrules you. Then what?Back the decision in public and say what you'd track so it can be revisited. Going around them for an ordinary business call is the wrong move.
- When would you go over your manager's head?Only for an ethics, legal or safety issue, and ideally after telling them you're going to. If that isn't safe, use the firm's own channel for it.
- How did the relationship change afterward?Give a sign it held, like being asked for your view on the next project. A disagreement that cost the relationship is a weaker story.
“I liked having feedback while the case was still fresh. I'd usually try another one straight after.”
More behavioral and fit
- Tell me about a time you took the initiative without being asked.
- Tell me about a time you led a group to a result that mattered.
- Tell me about a time you had to work closely with someone who saw a problem very differently from you.
- Tell me about a time you changed someone's mind.
- Tell me about a conflict you had with a teammate.
Consulting behavioral interview questionsAll interview questionsBehavioral interview practiceTimed video practiceHireVue interview questionsMcKinsey PEI questions
Ready for an interviewer that talks back?
Start the 7-day free trial and answer your first question out loud to the AI interviewer today.
Start your free week