Depreciation goes up by $10. Walk me through the three statements.

Assume a 25% tax rate. On the income statement, pretax income falls $10, taxes fall $2.50 and net income falls $7.50. On cash flow, add back $10, so cash rises $2.50. On the balance sheet, net PP&E falls $10 and retained earnings fall $7.50.

Updated

How a 90-point answer starts

I'll assume a 25% tax rate. Starting with the income statement, depreciation is an expense, so pre-tax income goes down by $10.

See the full answer, the 50 and 70 versions, and what moves each score up.

Practice this question free

Try the free three-statement model template

The numbers, step by step

Depreciation up $10, at a 25% tax rate, with the extra depreciation also deductible for tax.

Tax saved$10 × 25%
$2.50
Net income−$10 + $2.50
down $7.50
Cash from operations and cash−$7.50 + $10 added back
up $2.50
Total assets$2.50 cash − $10 net PP&E
down $7.50
Retained earnings, so it balancesFollows net income
down $7.50

What the interviewer listens for

  • Do you state a tax rate before you start?
  • Do you go in order: income statement, cash flow statement, balance sheet?
  • Do you give a number for every line and check that it balances?
  • Can you explain why cash goes up?

Common mistakes

  • Saying net income falls by the full $10.Taxes fall by $2.50 too, so net income is down only $7.50.
  • Saying cash goes down because an expense went up.Depreciation costs no cash, and cash rises by the tax saved.
  • Saying gross PP&E falls.Accumulated depreciation rises by $10, so it's net PP&E that is down.
  • Stopping before the check.Say that assets and liabilities plus equity both fall by $7.50.

Likely follow-ups

  • What if the extra depreciation is only for the books, not for tax?Book taxes still fall by $2.50 but cash taxes don't, so a deferred tax asset of $2.50 appears. Cash is unchanged, net PP&E is down $10, the deferred tax asset is up $2.50 and retained earnings are down $7.50, so it still balances.
  • What happens to the company's value in a DCF?Unlevered free cash flow rises by the $2.50 tax saving, so value goes up a little, as long as the depreciation is deductible for tax.
  • And if the $10 were amortization of an acquired intangible instead?The walk is the same, with intangible assets falling instead of PP&E, as long as the amortization is deductible for tax.

More finance technicals

Accounting interview questionsAll interview questionsFree technical questionsPaper LBO practice

Ready for an interviewer that talks back?

Start the 7-day free trial and answer your first technical question out loud to the AI interviewer today.

Start your free week