Situational judgment tests, formats, examples and scoring

A situational judgment test (SJT) shows you a realistic work scenario and asks how you would handle it, by rating, ranking or picking from several possible actions. It measures workplace judgment and behavior, such as integrity, customer care, teamwork and adaptability, not technical knowledge. Your answers are scored against a key, and SHL says its behavioral assessments are often used at the start of hiring to screen for fit. Soreno, an AI voice interview practice app for consulting and finance candidates, has free fit interview practice with no sign-up for the behavioral round that usually follows.

Updated

  • Scenarios, not knowledge. You judge actions in situations from the job you applied for.
  • Four common answer styles. Rate each option, rank them, pick most and least, or explain on video.
  • Effective and likely differ. Read whether the question asks what is best or what you would do.
  • Not always timed. Deutsche Bank says only its ability test is timed, and KPMG UK's ranking task is untimed.
  • Keyed by experts. Admissions SJTs like the UCAT compare your answers with a panel of experts.

How do you answer a situational judgment test?

Every SJT gives you a scenario and some possible actions. What changes is what you do with them. These four styles are the ones sourced to a test owner's own page, and the cards say whose.

Rank the options

Put the actions in order. Some tests ask what is most like you rather than what is best.

KPMG UK
Rank how you would respond
Timing
Untimed, about 20 minutes

Say it on video

On a video-based assessment, explain out loud what you would do in a hypothetical situation.

HireVue
What actions you would take
Most and least, best and worst, and branching testsOur explanation

Common variants you may meet, explained by our team rather than any one vendor. Your instructions screen says which one you have.

  1. Most and least

    Two picks per scenario

    You choose the action you'd be most likely to take and the one you'd be least likely to take. The least likely pick carries as much weight as the most likely, so don't rush it.

  2. Best and worst

    Effectiveness, not habit

    Same layout, but the question is which action works best and which works worst. Answer for the strongest response, even if it isn't what you'd usually do.

  3. Linear

    Fixed scenarios

    Every candidate sees the same scenarios in the same order. Each one stands alone.

  4. Branching

    The story moves with you

    The next scene depends on what you chose, often in a video or animated test. Treat each new scene as the situation you now have, not a verdict on your last answer.

A banking item we wrote, rated and scoredOurs, rating scale

At 7 p.m. you notice a colleague's table of trading multiples in tomorrow's client deck doesn't match the client's audited filings. Your associate is at dinner with the managing director. Rate each action from 1 to 4.

  1. Action A

    Our key: Ineffective (2)

    Quietly swap in the filing numbers and send the deck to print. Sample answer: Effective (3), scoring 2 of 3 on our illustration.

  2. Action B

    Our key: Counterproductive (1)

    Leave the colleague's table, since it is their section. Sample answer: Counterproductive (1), scoring 3 of 3 on our illustration.

  3. Action C

    Our key: Very effective (4)

    Check the filing, ask the colleague about any adjustment, and send your associate a short note with the corrected figures. Sample answer: Very effective (4), scoring 3 of 3 on our illustration.

  4. Action D

    Our key: Ineffective (2)

    Interrupt the associate's dinner meeting with a call. Sample answer: Counterproductive (1), scoring 2 of 3 on our illustration.

  5. Score

    10 of 12

    Our illustration, not any vendor's method: 3 points for matching the key and 1 fewer for each step away. The sample answer lost points on A, which hides a change from the team, and on D, where calling at once is clumsy but not harmful.

A consulting item we wrote, rankedOurs, ranking

Two weeks into a project, the client manager who controls the warehouse data keeps canceling your handoff calls at the last minute, citing quarter-end. Rank: A, escalate to the client's VP now. B, estimate the data from industry averages without telling anyone. C, send a short list of the three files you need so they can be shared without a call, and update your engagement manager. D, ask your engagement manager to raise it with the client lead.

  1. Our key

    C, D, A, B

    C solves the problem for a busy client and keeps your manager informed. D is a sensible next step if C fails. A escalates before you've adapted. B replaces client data with guesses.

  2. Sample answer

    C, A, D, B

    2 of 4 in the exact spot, and 2 places off in total. The top and bottom are right, which is where most of the judgment sits.

SJTs outside hiringAdmissions

Medical admissions use SJTs too, and their owners publish the format. They show how an SJT is keyed.

  1. AAMC PREview

    Rate the effectiveness of responses

    A standardized SJT with one section of 186 responses to rate in about 75 minutes, built with experts in academic medicine. By our calculation, that is about 24 seconds a response.

    AAMC: about the PREview exam
  2. UCAT

    Scored against a panel of experts

    The UCAT's Situational Judgement subtest has 69 questions in 26 minutes, about 23 seconds each by our calculation. Results come in four bands, and Band 1 means judgment similar to the panel of experts in most cases.

    UCAT: test format and scoring

From SHL Direct: situational judgement example, KPMG UK: graduate application process, HireVue: candidate FAQ, AAMC: about the PREview exam and UCAT: test format and scoring.

What does a situational judgment test measure?

Behavior at work, mapped to each publisher's own framework. Expect scenarios from the job you applied for.

  • SHL's competency framework

    SHL's Universal Competency Framework has three tiers: 8 general competency factors, 20 competency dimensions and 96 skills. SHL says it is firmly linked to observable behaviors.

  • Customer care, integrity, influence, adaptability

    Competencies SHL names for its library of multimedia SJTs, which present workplace scenarios and actions.

    Show what they listen for
    What interviewers listen for
    Our read: in banking items, integrity and accuracy usually decide the best option.
  • Decision making and interpersonal skills

    Sova describes its SJTs as assessing decision-making, problem-solving and interpersonal skills in realistic, job-related scenarios.

  • Behavior in context

    Cappfinity's Behaviour in Context uses interactive, varied formats that it says encourage honesty and prevent cheating, calibrated for levels from early talent to leaders.

  • Judgment across roles

    Talogy's Dilemmas series of SJTs measures 4 to 5 competencies in each part, with versions for managers, graduates, administrative, customer service and call center roles.

10 practice scenarios for situational judgment tests

Written by our team, never a vendor's own items. Decide your answer first, then open the note for our ranking and why.

Banking3 scenarios

Accuracy, integrity and the client.

  1. On Friday you find an old-quarter ratio in a pitch book appendix that flatters the client. The teammate who built it says leave it so the deck goes out on time. What do you do?

    Our ranking

    Best: show them the newer filing, fix the appendix and any linked page, and flag a short delay to the associate. Worst: send it as is. Practice it, see a model answer

  2. You spot an error in a model that already went to the client. Rank: tell your associate now, fix it quietly in the next version, or wait to see if anyone notices.

    Our ranking

    Tell your associate now, with the size of the impact and a fix. Fixing it quietly comes second. Waiting is last. Practice it, see a model answer

  3. Two VPs each give you an urgent task due at 9 a.m. You can't do both. What is most and least effective?

    Our ranking

    Most: tell both, say what you can deliver by when, and let them settle the priority. Least: pick one silently and miss the other. Practice it, see a model answer

Consulting4 scenarios

Clients, teams and ambiguity.

  1. The client manager who holds the data you need keeps canceling calls. Rank escalating to the VP, estimating the data yourself, sending a short file list, and asking your manager to raise it.

    Our ranking

    Our key: C, D, A, B. Make it easy for the client first, then escalate through your manager.

  2. A teammate's analysis has a flaw the day before a client meeting. They are defensive when you mention it. What do you do?

    Our ranking

    Best: walk them through the numbers privately and agree a fix together, then tell the manager if the deadline moves. Worst: present around it without saying anything. Practice it, see a model answer

  3. Your manager asks for a market size by tomorrow with almost no data. Rate: ask for a day more, build a rough estimate with clear assumptions, or wait for the client's data.

    Our ranking

    A rough estimate with stated assumptions is very effective. Asking for more time is ineffective. Waiting is counterproductive. Practice it, see a model answer

  4. You disagree with your manager's recommendation the night before it goes to the client. What is most likely to work?

    Our ranking

    Raise it with your manager that night with your evidence, then back the team's final call. Raising it first in front of the client is least effective. Practice it, see a model answer

Running a team1 scenario

Our own scenario, not SHL's.

  1. You lead four analysts in a month-end close. Two keep missing handoffs to each other and blame each other in the team chat. The close is in three days. What do you do?

    Our ranking

    Best: meet the two together, agree who hands off what by when, and check the next handoff yourself. Worst: take the work over yourself, which fixes the week but not the problem.

Video2 scenarios

No options. Say your answer in about a minute.

  1. A client emails you directly asking for numbers your manager hasn't approved. What would you do?

    Our ranking

    Thank them, say when they'll have it, and check with your manager before sending anything.

  2. You join a project halfway and the team's tracker is out of date. What would you do in your first two days?

    Our ranking

    Ask the manager for priorities, update the tracker with the team, and say what you've changed.

Mistakes, prep plan and FAQ

Mistakes that sink SJT scores
  • Answering what you'd do when it asks what is best

    A best and worst test wants the strongest response. A most and least likely test wants your honest behavior.

  • Escalating everything

    Going over someone's head before trying a direct fix rarely tops the key, unless ethics or compliance is at stake.

  • Rating every option the same

    On a rating scale, judge each action on its own. Two options can both be effective, but not every option.

  • Gaming a personality-style ranking

    When a task asks what is most like you, as KPMG UK's does, guessing an ideal profile can work against you.

How to prepare for a situational judgment test

Our plan, for the week before and the test itself.

  1. Before

    Read the employer's values

    SHL says its SJTs use situations you could meet in the job you applied for. Note the three or four behaviors the firm says it hires for.

  2. Before

    Try the publisher's practice test

    SHL Direct has a free practice SJT. Sova's preparation hub has practice tests with situational judgment questions too.

    From SHL Direct: practice tests and Sova: candidate preparation hub.

  3. During

    Find what is at stake

    Ask who is affected, what is still working and what breaks if you do nothing. Protect the client and the facts first.

  4. During

    Rule out the extremes

    Hiding an error, ignoring it, or escalating before trying a direct fix usually sit at the bottom.

  5. During

    Prefer direct, collaborative action

    Fix what you can, involve the right person, and keep your manager informed. Escalate at once only for an ethics or compliance issue.

  6. After

    Get ready for the interview

    Deutsche Bank, for one, follows its SJT and tests with a pre-recorded video interview. Start telling your stories out loud now.

    HireVue interview guide

What do banks and firms say about their SJTs?

Only what each employer's or vendor's own page says. Our firm guides cover the rest of each process.

Deutsche Bank

Order
SJT, behavioral questionnaire, ability test
Then
Pre-recorded video interview
Timed
Only the ability test

Deutsche Bank's student FAQ says the online assessment involves a situational judgment test, a behavioral questionnaire and an ability test, followed by a pre-recorded video interview, and that only the ability test is timed.

KPMG UK

Task
Rank responses to scenarios
Timing
Untimed, allow 20 minutes
Practice
SHL's practice tests

KPMG UK's graduate page says the skills assessment shows scenarios and asks you to rank how you would think, feel or respond, picking the answer most like you at work. It is untimed, with 20 minutes suggested.

Cappfinity

Sectors
Banking, professional services and more
Blend
Behavioral, cognitive and technical

Cappfinity says its off-the-shelf skills assessments are aligned to sectors including banking and professional services, and blend behavioral, cognitive and technical capability in one experience.

After the SJT, the interview

Soreno's AI interviewer asks behavioral and case questions out loud, follows up like a real interviewer, and scores every answer, quoting your own words.

Questions people ask

What is a situational judgment test?

A test that shows you realistic work scenarios and asks you to judge several possible actions. SHL says its SJTs assess your ability to choose the most appropriate action in workplace situations.

Is it judgment or judgement?

Both. Judgment is the usual US spelling and judgement the British one, which UK-based vendors such as SHL use in product names.

How are situational judgment tests scored?

Against a key set for the role. The UCAT compares answers with a panel of experts, and SHL's behavioral reports give employers a match score for the role.

Are situational judgment tests timed?

Not always. Deutsche Bank says only its ability test is timed, and KPMG UK's ranking assessment is untimed with 20 minutes suggested. Admissions SJTs like the UCAT are timed.

Can you practice a situational judgment test?

Yes. SHL Direct has a free practice SJT, and Sova's preparation hub includes situational judgment questions. Practice reading what each question asks, then the scenarios.

Can I take an SJT on my phone?

Often. SHL says its behavioral assessments are designed mobile-first for any device. Check your invite for the employer's setup.

Keep going