Cornerstone Research case interview, economics meets law

Cornerstone Research's interview process for Analyst and Summer Analyst candidates has two rounds: two virtual 30-minute first-round interviews, then a multi-hour final round in one of its offices. You get a different case interview in each round to review and discuss, and Cornerstone publishes two practice case examples on securities damages and intellectual property lost profits. Its cases test how you isolate the causal impact of alleged misconduct from economy-wide, industry-wide and company factors, while interviewers say behavioral preparation on collaboration, conflict management and mentorship matters as much or more. Cornerstone has you review and discuss each case, so practice aloud. Soreno, an AI voice interview practice app for consulting, investment banking and other finance candidates, runs a free sample case with no sign-up.

Updated

  • Two rounds. Two virtual 30-minute interviews, then a multi-hour final at an office.
  • A new case each round. The process is identical for Analyst and Summer Analyst roles.
  • Two public case examples. Securities damages and patent lost profits, with analysis.
  • Behavioral counts. Expect collaboration, conflict management and mentorship.
  • No AI in interviews. It's fine for preparation but not during interviews or assessments.

A worked case: how much was the overcharge?

Cornerstone's examples turn on one idea: compare what happened with what would have happened without the alleged conduct. Here is that idea in an antitrust setting.

Example case: a price-fixing claimSoreno's invented case

Our own case, not Cornerstone's. The numbers are made up, and real expert work relies on far richer data and statistics.

  1. The prompt

    An $8M claim

    Buyers say two makers of a chemical fixed prices for a year. The price rose from $10 to $14 per unit, on 2,000,000 units, so they claim $8M. You support the defense's expert.

  2. The flaw

    Before and after isn't enough

    That claim blames the whole rise on the conduct. Ask what else could have raised prices, such as raw material costs, demand or the economy.

    How to build an issue tree
  3. The method

    Find a but-for price

    Look for a similar market untouched by the alleged conduct, or use a regression on costs and demand from a clean period. Here, a comparable region's price rose from $10 to $12.50 over the same time.

  4. The math

    $1.50 a unit, or $3M

    Without the conduct, the price would have been about $12.50. Actual $14 minus $12.50 is $1.50. Across 2,000,000 units, that's $3M, not $8M.

    Free case math drills
  5. Conclude

    Say what could break it

    Give the $3M and its key assumption: the comparison region really is comparable. Then say you'd test that, for example whether its costs and buyers look alike.

    See a real sample report

From Cornerstone: case examples.

What Cornerstone says it assesses

Its analyst interview page names four things it assesses, its interviewers add behavioral dimensions, and its associate case page adds team leadership and your ability to direct a team.

  • Thought process

    Break questions into smaller parts and analyze the issue from several perspectives.

  • Comprehension

    Listen actively, take notes and ask thoughtful questions. Your interviewers are there to guide you.

  • Communication

    Clearly say how you're thinking. A Boston principal says it's fine to take a moment before you respond.

  • Applying feedback in real time

    It names your ability to receive feedback and use it right away as part of what it assesses.

  • Collaboration

    A Washington manager says be ready to explain how you handled collaboration, conflict and mentoring.

From Cornerstone: what we look for.

Cornerstone's process for analysts

Cornerstone says the interview process is identical for Analyst and Summer Analyst roles. Associate and Summer Associate candidates have their own application requirements and case interview examples that also assess team leadership and your ability to direct a team.

Application, then two rounds
  1. Apply

    Cover letter, resume, transcript

    All through its career portal, whatever your school's system. Note any office preferences in your cover letter. Missing materials mean your application won't be considered.

    From Cornerstone: how to apply.

  2. Round 1

    Two virtual interviews

    Each lasts 30 minutes, and the round includes a case to review and discuss.

    From Cornerstone: what we look for.

  3. Final round

    Multi-hour, at an office

    You get a different case from the first round. Treat it as a chance to learn too: an interviewer calls it a two-way street.

    From Cornerstone: what we look for.

  4. Associates

    MBA and PhD materials

    Cover letter and resume. Full-time PhD candidates also send three letters of reference and a sample research paper, while Summer Associate PhD candidates include an unofficial university transcript.

    From Cornerstone: associate application.

Check its recruiting events calendar for on-campus recruiting events and submission deadlines. Candidates can apply for roles based in the US, the UK or Belgium.

12 cause and damages practice questions

Written by us. Cornerstone says its cases suit many backgrounds, so these lean on reasoning rather than legal knowledge. Three behavioral questions close the list.

Separating causes4 questions

Ask what else could explain the number.

  1. A company's stock falls 30% the month a lawsuit says it hid bad news. How much of that is from the hidden news?

    What a strong answer does

    List market, industry and other company news. Say how you'd use a clean period to predict the stock's move without the news.

  2. A retailer says a false ad by a rival cost it 20% of sales. How would you test this?

    What a strong answer does

    Compare timing, stores or regions with and without the ad, and check other causes like weather or prices.

  3. A drug's sales dropped after a generic entered early. What would sales have been otherwise?

    What a strong answer does

    Use the trend before entry, similar drugs and any changes in the market. Then compare your line with what happened.

  4. An airline merger is followed by higher fares. Did the merger cause it?

    What a strong answer does

    Compare routes where the two airlines overlapped with similar routes where they didn't, over the same period.

Damages and value3 questions

Get the logic straight before any number.

  1. A court found a rival used your client's patented process. How would you estimate lost profits?

    What a strong answer does

    Ask whether the rival's customers would really have bought from your client. Then multiply the sales that would have shifted by the profit on each.

  2. A supplier broke a contract and a factory stopped for 10 days. What's the loss?

    What a strong answer does

    Lost sales times profit per unit, less costs saved, and less any sales made up later. Say which of those is hardest to prove.

  3. Sales fell by 40,000 units, but 10,000 of that was a market decline. At $15 profit a unit, what are damages?

    What a strong answer does

    30,000 units at $15 is $450,000. Then say what might still be overstated.

Data and reasoning2 questions

Say what the data can and can't show.

  1. How would you find out whether two firms sell to the same customers?

    What a strong answer does

    Compare customer lists, sizes, regions and product uses. Overlap suggests they compete directly. Little overlap weakens a claim of lost sales.

  2. You're given a chart where a price and a cost move together. What do you say?

    What a strong answer does

    Correlation isn't cause. Ask which moves first and what else moved, and propose how you'd test it.

Behavioral questions3 questions

A Cornerstone manager names these three dimensions.

  1. Tell me about a time you collaborated with people who worked very differently from you.

    What a strong answer does

    Say what differed, what you adjusted and what the team achieved because of it.

  2. Tell me about a time you worked through a disagreement on a team.

    What a strong answer does

    Show how you listened and what you changed. End with the working relationship as well as the result.

  3. Tell me about a time you mentored or helped someone less experienced.

    What a strong answer does

    Be specific on how you helped and what they could then do alone.

More to prepare with

Habits Cornerstone warns about
  • Over-preparing the case alone

    A manager says to prepare the behavioral parts as much as the case, or more.

  • Not listening

    A principal calls active listening her best advice, because they're looking for people to collaborate with.

  • Using AI during an interview

    Cornerstone doesn't permit it in interviews or assessments.

  • Sending an incomplete application

    It won't consider applications with missing materials.

How to prepare for Cornerstone

Cornerstone's own tips first, then steps we suggest.

  1. Cornerstone's advice

    Work its two case examples

    It says these examples help you prepare. We'd try each key question before reading its suggestion and analysis.

    From Cornerstone: case examples.

  2. Cornerstone's advice

    Break it down, aloud

    Split questions into parts, think about several perspectives, take notes and say your thought process.

    From Cornerstone: what we look for.

  3. Cornerstone's advice

    Prepare past examples

    Have stories on collaboration, conflict and mentorship ready, since interviewers can only learn your style if you tell them.

    From Cornerstone: what we look for.

  4. From its case

    Know what a regression does

    Its securities case uses a regression on a market index and an industry index, fit on the year before the alleged conduct. Know the idea and why that period is used.

    From Cornerstone: case examples.

  5. Cornerstone's advice

    Go to a recruiting event

    It encourages applicants to attend, and its calendar lists events and deadlines by campus.

    From Cornerstone: how to apply.

  6. Our suggestion

    Learn the but-for idea

    Practice asking what would have happened without the conduct, until it's your first move on any damages question.

  7. Our suggestion

    Rehearse being redirected

    Have someone interrupt you with a hint, then use it right away, since it assesses how you apply feedback in real time.

    Free sample case

Cornerstone's two case examples

Free on cornerstone.com, with key questions, suggestions and analysis. The summaries are ours.

Case 1: SecuritiesStock price damages

Four key questions. Shareholders of a tech firm claim a $40 a share drop as damages. You find the flaw and how to separate market, industry and other news. The team's regression and event study left only $3 that might relate to the allegations.

Cornerstone: case examples
Case 2: Intellectual propertyLost profits

Four key questions on Duff Products Corporation and ACME Manufacturing Company. ACME claims hundreds of millions of dollars in lost earnings opportunities after Duff used its patented manufacturing techniques. Customer data show ACME sold directly to large institutions while Duff sold primarily to retail chains for individual consumers, econometric analysis links ACME's revenue decline to a new technology that made its technology obsolete, and deducting variable labor and material costs and fixed manufacturing equipment costs leaves little lost profit.

Cornerstone: case examples

Find the real cause, then say it clearly

Soreno's AI interviewer runs cases out loud, gives you real-time follow-ups to work with and scores how clearly you explained your thinking. Use it for practice only, since Cornerstone doesn't permit AI during interviews. Free for 7 days. Soreno is not affiliated with Cornerstone Research.

Questions people ask

How many rounds are in the Cornerstone Research interview?

Two for Analyst and Summer Analyst roles: two virtual 30-minute interviews, then a multi-hour final at one of its offices.

Does each round have a case?

Yes. Cornerstone says the case is an important part of each round, and you get a different one at each.

Do I need economics or law to do the case?

A Cornerstone manager says its cases are designed to be accessible to a wide variety of experiences and academic backgrounds.

Can I use AI in a Cornerstone interview?

No. It accepts AI as a preparation tool, but doesn't permit it during interviews and assessments.

What does an Associate need to apply?

A cover letter and resume. PhD candidates also send three letters of reference and a sample research paper.

What is a Cornerstone analyst's job?

Working on case teams with an expert, senior consultants and other analysts, on research, quantitative analysis, case strategy and preparing experts for testimony.

Is Soreno affiliated with Cornerstone Research?

No. Soreno is independent of Cornerstone Research and wrote the worked case and every practice question here.

Keep going