Why would a company try an out-of-court restructuring first?

Lead with cost, speed and less damage to the business. Name the tools, like amend and extends, exchanges and new money, then explain the holdout problem and why a prepackaged Chapter 11 is the common way to bind holdouts.

The numbers, step by step

The exchange from the answer, in $ millions, with invented numbers: $500 of bonds offered 70 cents in new notes, and 85% of holders accept.

Bonds exchanged$500 × 85%

$425

New notes issued$425 × 70 cents

$297.5

Holdouts kept at full value$500 × 15%

$75

Debt after the exchange$297.5 + $75

$372.5

Debt cut$500 − $372.5

$127.5

Debt cut if every holder accepted$500 × 30%

$150

What the interviewer listens for

• Do you lead with cost, speed and damage to the business?
• Do you name concrete out-of-court tools?
• Do you explain the holdout problem and why it exists?
• Do you know a prepack combines both routes?

Common mistakes

• Saying out of court is always better.It can't bind holdouts, stop lawsuits with an automatic stay or reject bad leases.
• Assuming a majority of bondholders can cut everyone's principal.Payment terms need each holder's consent.
• Thinking out of court means only bond exchanges, when bank amendments, new money and asset sales are just as common.
• Forgetting tax.Debt cancelled at a discount can create taxable income, and excluding it reduces the company's NOLs and other tax attributes.

Likely follow-ups

• What can Chapter 11 do that an out-of-court deal can't?Stop creditor actions with the automatic stay, bind dissenting creditors through class voting and cramdown, reject unprofitable leases and contracts, and give DIP lenders priority.
• What's the difference between a prepack and a prearranged case?In a prepack the votes are collected before filing. In a prearranged case key creditors sign a support agreement before filing, and the formal vote happens during the case.
• What's an exit consent?Holders who accept an exchange also vote to strip covenants from the old bonds, which only needs a majority, so holding out leaves you with weaker bonds.

More finance technicals

• What signs tell you a company is heading for distress?
• What's the difference between Chapter 11 and Chapter 7?
• What is a 363 sale?
• A company in Chapter 11 is worth $600 million. Claims are a $50 million DIP, $10 million of admin claims, $300 million of first lien, $200 million of second lien, $150 million of unsecured bonds and $50 million of trade claims. Who recovers what?
• What is DIP financing, and why would anyone lend to a bankrupt company?

All interview questionsFree technical questionsPaper LBO practice