Unstructured Case Interview: How to Structure Open-Ended Business Problems
When candidates talk about an unstructured case interview, they mean an open-ended problem-solving conversation where a memorized formula will not fit. On their official careers pages, both McKinsey and BCG state that case study interviews do not have a single right or logical solution, and McKinsey specifically advises candidates to share custom solutions rather than standard frameworks. What matters most is how you organize your approach from scratch, clarify assumptions, and talk your interviewer through your reasoning step by step.
Updated
What candidates mean by an unstructured case interview
Candidates use the phrase unstructured case interview to describe a broad, ambiguous business prompt where you cannot simply plug in a generic profit tree. On their official interviewing pages, McKinsey and BCG call this step the problem-solving interview or the case study interview. Instead of testing whether you memorized a textbook template, the interviewer presents a realistic business challenge to evaluate the quality of your reasoning when the path forward is not obvious.
This means an open-ended prompt is not a trick to make you guess a secret number. It is a test of how you bring order to a messy question. You can read our guide to case interview frameworks to see how building from first principles differs from reciting a template, or Practice a case free, no sign-up to test your opening out loud.
- Goal of the format: Simulate real-world client problems and evaluate how you think critically, structure an approach, and communicate.
- What firms reject: Memorized, standard frameworks forced onto a business scenario that needs a specific approach.
- What firms evaluate: Problem-solving, analytical, and communication skills, alongside business intuition, logical thinking, and creativity.
Why standard frameworks fail on open-ended prompts
A standard framework fails when it answers a general textbook question instead of the specific question your interviewer just asked. Look at the official practice cases on McKinsey's careers site. In the Talbot Trucks case, the first question asks what information to collect to understand the attractiveness of producing and selling electric trucks (eTrucks) in Europe. In the Diconsa case, McKinsey investigates whether a Mexican government-owned chain of 22,000 rural stores can provide basic financial services for the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.
If you respond to the Diconsa prompt by reciting a generic four-part market entry list, you miss the actual question about investigating whether a network of 22,000 rural stores in Mexico can provide basic financial services.
McKinsey's helpful hints on these cases explain what to do instead. First, develop an overall approach before diving into details. Second, take time to organize your thoughts before answering, which shows your interviewer that you have a logical approach and can think in an organized way regardless of the accuracy of the outcome. Third, when an interviewer raises specific challenges, consider the exact issues raised in the question and group your thoughts around them so your answers stay relevant. If you want to practice creating clean categories that do not overlap, review our examples of MECE structuring.
Five steps to solve an open-ended case prompt
When an interviewer gives you a broad question with little data, follow the step-by-step habits outlined across BCG's case preparation page and McKinsey's practice case hints. These steps keep you from freezing or rambling.
- 1. Listen actively and write down the core facts. At the start of every McKinsey sample case, the firm advises you to write down important information and ask the interviewer to explain anything that is not clear.
- 2. Pause to organize an overall approach. Do not rush your response or dive straight into isolated details. Take a moment to build your top-level groups on paper first. Even when a question feels casual, grouping your thoughts around the issues in the prompt keeps your answer structured.
- 3. Clarify your assumptions out loud. When a prompt leaves out details, state what you are assuming and check whether the interviewer agrees. BCG lists clarifying assumptions and showing your thinking as core habits for every case.
- 4. Look for non-obvious trends when data appears. Open-ended cases still introduce charts, survey tables, or cost breakdowns mid-conversation. McKinsey advises taking time to note down observations and challenging yourself to identify trends that are not immediately obvious from the data.
- 5. Write out your math on paper and narrate every step. Calculators are not allowed in McKinsey case interviews. Write your calculations on paper, take your time instead of rushing, and talk your interviewer through your steps.
Communication habits that show your thinking
In a conversational or loosely structured case, the interviewer is testing how it feels to work with you on a real team. Both McKinsey and BCG describe their interview processes as a two-way conversation. On its interview process page, BCG names five qualities its consulting interviewers look for: Integrity, Intellectual Curiosity, Creative Thinking, Collaborative Mindset, and Drive.
BCG also publishes a clear list of what to do and what to avoid during a case study interview. Reviewing this list before you practice helps you replace nervous habits with clear communication.
BCG Case Interview Preparation: Official Do and Don't List
| Do in your case interview | Don't do in your case interview |
|---|---|
| Listen Actively | Panic Under Pressure |
| Be Yourself | Rush Your Response |
| Think Structurally | Overcomplicate Solutions |
| Communicate Clearly | Ignore Feedback |
| Clarify Assumptions | Stay Silent |
| Show Your Thinking | Interrupt |
How to manage your paper when there is no formal framework
When an interviewer asks a succession of open-ended qualitative and quantitative questions, drawing one giant decision tree on your first sheet of paper can trap you. The conversation will move to new angles, and a rigid diagram quickly gets cluttered. Our team recommends a simple two-column paper setup that matches the official advice from McKinsey and BCG.
On your first sheet, draw a line down the middle. Use the left column to write down the client's exact facts, numbers, and goal as you listen. Leave the right column blank for your clarifying questions and the two or three main groups you will use to answer Question 1.
When the interviewer shifts to a new qualitative challenge or a calculation, start a fresh horizontal section below your first one. Write the keywords of the new question at the top of that section, then list two or three grouped headings underneath before you speak. This habit forces you to group your thoughts around the specific issues raised in each question, rather than trying to force Question 4 back into the boxes you drew for Question 1. When numbers appear, use a clean corner of the page so you can read each step out loud without losing your place.
Worked math example: handling sudden numbers in an open-ended case
Even a case that starts with broad, qualitative discussions about virtual channels and employee roles can suddenly turn into a financial calculation. In McKinsey's Beautify practice case, McKinsey evaluates whether training the majority of beauty consultants at a prestige cosmetics company with €1.3 billion in revenues to use virtual channels to connect with customers could be profitable.
Below is an invented numerical scenario written by our team, built around Beautify's official €1.3 billion revenue figure, showing how to work through a profitability calculation on paper and narrate it out loud. In our team's invented scenario, assume that shifting beauty consultants to virtual channels lifts annual revenues by 5%, requires an upfront training and technology outlay of €65 million at the start of Year 1, and adds €15 million in ongoing yearly operating costs starting in Year 1. How many years will it take for this investment to break even and turn profitable? If you want to build speed on arithmetic like this, try our case interview math drills.
- Official case fact and our invented practice assumptions: Beautify is a prestige cosmetics company with €1.3 billion in annual revenues. For this worked example written by our team, we use three invented inputs: a 5% annual incremental revenue lift starting in Year 1, a €65 million upfront investment in training and technology, and €15 million in ongoing annual operating costs.
- Step 1 (Our example setup): State the break-even rule before calculating any digits. The project turns profitable when cumulative incremental revenue exceeds cumulative total costs, or equivalently, when the cumulative net annual contribution (incremental annual revenue minus ongoing annual operating cost) pays back the €65 million upfront outlay.
- Step 2 (Our example step): Calculate annual incremental revenue from the €1.3 billion baseline. Write €1.3 billion on your paper as €1,300 million so every number shares the same unit. Multiply €1,300 million by 5%: 10% of €1,300 million is €130 million, so half of that (5%) is €65 million in incremental revenue per year.
- Step 3 (Our example step): Subtract the ongoing annual operating cost from the annual incremental revenue to find the net annual contribution. Take €65 million in annual incremental revenue and subtract €15 million in annual operating costs: €65 million minus €15 million equals €50 million in net annual contribution toward paying off the upfront investment.
- Step 4 (Our example step): Track the cumulative balance year by year against the €65 million upfront outlay. At the end of Year 1, the €50 million net contribution covers €50 million of the €65 million upfront outlay, leaving €15 million still to recover (€65 million minus €50 million equals €15 million). In Year 2, the project generates another €50 million in net contribution, bringing cumulative net contribution to €100 million against the €65 million upfront cost (a net cumulative profit of €35 million by the end of Year 2). If the revenue and costs occur evenly across the year, the remaining €15 million is recovered in €15 million divided by €50 million, which is 0.3 years (about 3.6 months) into Year 2, or 1.3 years total.
- Step 5 (How to say it out loud to your interviewer): "To see when the virtual advisor investment turns profitable, I will compare the net annual gain against the €65 million upfront cost. Starting from €1,300 million in baseline revenue, a 5% lift adds €65 million per year. Subtracting the €15 million ongoing yearly cost leaves €50 million in net contribution each year. At the end of Year 1, we are still €15 million short of the €65 million upfront outlay, so the project turns profitable during Year 2, at 1.3 years if cash flows are even across the year."
Three official open-ended prompts to rehearse out loud
The best way to get comfortable with open-ended questions is to practice organizing an answer out loud. Below are three real qualitative prompts from McKinsey's official practice cases, paired with a checklist written by our team on how to structure your spoken response. You can also browse more prompts in our collection of consulting case study examples.
- Exercise 1: Scoping a new market (from McKinsey's Talbot Trucks case). Official prompt: What information would you want to collect to understand the attractiveness for Talbot Trucks in producing and selling electric trucks (eTrucks) in Europe? Our practice checklist: Take time to organize your thoughts on paper first. Develop an overall approach before diving into details by grouping your information needs into logical areas, such as customer demand, eTruck economics and technology, manufacturing feasibility, and market or regulatory factors. State your main groups first, then offer to go deeper into one.
- Exercise 2: Evaluating a virtual channel transition (from McKinsey's Beautify case). Official case focus: Evaluating whether training the majority of beauty consultants at a prestige cosmetics company (with €1.3 billion in revenues) to use virtual channels to connect with customers could be profitable. Our practice checklist: Separate employee and operational factors (training needs, incentives, and virtual platform readiness) from customer and financial factors (personalized consultations, easy reordering or loyalty perks, incremental revenue vs. training costs).
- Exercise 3: Assessing rural network feasibility (from McKinsey's Diconsa case). Official case focus: Investigating whether a Mexican government-owned chain of 22,000 rural stores can provide basic financial services for the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. Our practice checklist: Follow McKinsey's hint to consider the specific issues raised in the question and group your thoughts around them. Organize your investigation into clear buckets: rural customer needs and adoption, operational readiness across the 22,000 stores, financial sustainability, and regulatory or partner requirements.
Rules on using AI tools, notes, and calculators
Using AI to rehearse out loud before your interview is welcomed by firms, provided you follow strict integrity rules during the actual assessment and interview. On its interviewing page under AI in the Hiring Process, McKinsey states that when used responsibly, AI is a valuable tool that supports preparation, just as candidates have long sought feedback from mentors, friends, or family.
Specifically, McKinsey encourages using AI during preparation to practice interview questions and to ask AI to explain concepts or frameworks as part of your prep. By contrast, using AI to misrepresent yourself or to generate real-time answers during an interview is not allowed.
For virtual interviews, McKinsey advises keeping a laptop charger, pen and paper, and water within reach, and disabling any previously installed AI software such as note-taking tools or virtual assistants so they do not unintentionally record or assist with the interview. You can see a real sample report on Soreno to see how practicing out loud with an AI interviewer scores your structure, content, and communication during prep, or Practice a case free, no sign-up whenever you are ready to rehearse.
From BCG Careers: Consulting Case Study Interview Preparation, BCG Careers: Consulting Interview Process, McKinsey Careers: Interviewing at McKinsey, McKinsey Careers: Beautify Practice Case, McKinsey Careers: Talbot Trucks Practice Case and McKinsey Careers: Diconsa Practice Case.
1 practice question and sample answer
Say your answer out loud first, then read the sample answer.
Practice question
Practice prompt (based on McKinsey's Diconsa sample case): McKinsey has been asked to investigate and assess the possibility of using Diconsa, a Mexican government-owned chain of 22,000 rural stores, to provide a set of basic financial services for the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation to supplement the limited number of state-owned bank branches. What should the team investigate to determine whether the Diconsa network could and should be used to provide these services?
Sample answer. Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. Before I dive into details, I want to make sure I understand the objective: we are assessing whether the 22,000 rural Diconsa stores in Mexico can and should offer basic financial services to supplement state-owned bank branches. To answer both whether Diconsa could do this operationally and whether it should do this strategically, I would organize our investigation into four areas. First, rural resident needs and demand: which basic financial services matter most to rural residents, and would they trust and use their local Diconsa store for those transactions? Second, store operational readiness: do the 22,000 stores have the infrastructure, cash handling capacity, security, and staff capabilities required to offer financial services? Third, financial economics: what are the upfront setup and ongoing operating costs across the store network compared to the expected funding or transaction revenues? Fourth, regulatory and partner feasibility: what banking rules or state-owned bank agreements are required to allow retail stores to provide financial services? I would start by sizing resident demand and store readiness to see if the basic service model is workable.
This response follows McKinsey's official helpful hints and BCG's communication guidelines: it confirms the objective from the prompt, establishes an overall four-part approach before dropping into details, builds categories fit specifically to rural benefit recipients and Diconsa's 22,000-store network rather than reciting a generic framework, and suggests a clear starting point.
Practice the case interview, out loud
Soreno's AI interviewer runs a full case one question at a time, checks your math and scores your structure, any time you have 30 minutes.
Questions people ask
Should I memorize standard frameworks for a case interview?
No. McKinsey's official interviewing page states that there is not one logical solution to a problem-solving interview, and advises candidates to listen carefully and share solutions built for the specific scenario rather than standard frameworks.
What matters most if a case interview question has no single right answer?
According to BCG's case interview preparation guide, there is not always a single right answer in a case study interview. What matters most is how you approach the problem, think structurally, clarify assumptions, and demonstrate the quality of your reasoning.
How should I start when an interviewer asks a broad, open-ended question?
McKinsey's practice case hints advise you to write down important information, ask the interviewer to explain anything that is not clear, take time to organize your thoughts before answering, and develop an overall approach before diving into details.
Can I use a calculator if math comes up in an open-ended case?
In McKinsey's problem-solving interviews, calculators are not allowed. You should write out your calculations on paper, take your time rather than rushing, and talk the interviewer through your steps so they can follow your logic and help you if needed.
Is it allowed to practice case interview questions with AI?
Yes. McKinsey's AI in the Hiring Process guidelines explicitly encourage practicing interview questions and asking AI to explain concepts or frameworks during prep, while generating real-time responses during an interview is not allowed.
More guides
- Environmental Consulting Interview Questions and Answers
- McKinsey Acceptance Rate: Official Hiring Process & Stages
- Risk Consulting Interview Questions and Answers (2026)
- Consulting Presentation Slides: Structure, Charts & Build
- FTI Consulting Salary: Filings, Benchmarks & Pay (2026)
- Management Consulting Slide Deck: Structure and Guide
- CaseBasix Alternatives for Case Interview Prep (2026)
- Consulting Firm Hierarchy: Ranks at McKinsey, BCG and Bain
- Consulting Strategy Group: Services, Pay, and Vetting
- Deloitte Discovery Intern: How to Apply and Interview
- KPMG Verbal Reasoning Test: Format, Example and Prep
- Marketing and Strategy Consulting Firms Guide (2026)