Presentation Case: How to Structure, Analyze and Present a Consulting Case
In consulting recruiting, a presentation case is a business scenario where you review data documents or prompts, structure an approach, run calculations, and present your reasoning and recommendation. Formats range from live problem-solving interviews at McKinsey and BCG to BCG's 45-minute online case, which has more than 20 questions across several documents describing one business scenario. Interviewers judge how you structure the problem and explain your steps rather than looking for a single right answer.
Updated
What a presentation case tests in consulting
When you get a business case to analyze and present, the firm is testing how you handle a realistic client problem from start to finish. On its case interview preparation page, BCG calls the case study interview a problem-solving interview where you structure your approach, ask thoughtful questions, analyze data, do quick calculations, and identify the most important factors. BCG also runs a team interview for client-facing roles that assesses problem-solving, analytical, and communication skills.
Some rounds give you a packet of charts and tables to work through under a timer. BCG's online case practice booklet (2019) gives you 45 minutes to answer more than 20 questions based on several documents describing a single business scenario, with new documents opening as you move through the case. In its live problem-solving interview, McKinsey presents a client scenario and asks you to talk through your logic, calculations, and recommendation step by step.
Both formats test the same core skills: business judgment, logical reasoning, quantitative work, and clear communication. You can Practice a case free, no sign-up to see how your structure, math, and recommendation hold up out loud, or read our collection of consulting case study examples across case types.
- Live problem-solving case: You hear the client scenario, organize your thoughts, ask clarifying questions, work through data with pen and paper, and present your findings to the interviewer.
- Multi-document online case: You read a sequence of briefing documents and exhibits against a clock, calculate the key drivers, and select or state conclusions from the data provided.
How to structure your case presentation
Both McKinsey and BCG warn against rushing into an answer or reciting a memorized checklist. On its interviewing page, McKinsey notes that there is not one logical solution, so you should listen carefully and share tailored solutions rather than standard frameworks. In its Diconsa practice case, McKinsey advises taking time to organize your thoughts and developing an overall approach before you get into the details.
When you present your structure or answer a qualitative question, group your points around the specific problems the client actually faces. If a state-owned bank in the Diconsa case is worried about minimal education, unfamiliarity with banking products, and high crime and fraud in rural areas, your presentation branches should directly address customer education, simple product design, and security.
On its case preparation page, BCG lists twelve habits that separate strong case presentations from weak ones.
- Listen actively to the client scenario and write down the core objective.
- Think structurally and build an overall approach before calculating details.
- Clarify assumptions with your interviewer whenever a term or goal is ambiguous.
- Communicate clearly and show your thinking out loud as you work.
- Do not panic under pressure, rush your response, or stay silent for long stretches.
- Do not overcomplicate solutions, ignore feedback from the interviewer, or interrupt.
The numbers and business drivers that matter
When you open a set of case documents, not every number on the page matters equally. Across McKinsey and BCG official practice cases, the math turns on four groups of drivers: demand and market growth, capacity and utilization, pricing and third-party revenue splits, and investment payback.
Start by checking how each number is defined. In the BCG Med-Lines practice case, a table of 10 million total ferry departures does not mean 10 million individual passengers traveled, because a tourist taking a connecting ferry from Athens to Mykonos and then on to Rhodes buys two separate tickets. Always separate units, trips, and unique customers before you multiply.
Core drivers in official BCG and McKinsey practice cases
| Driver category | What to check in the exhibits | Official case example |
|---|---|---|
| Market and demand | Macro correlations, demographic splits, and compound annual growth versus one-year growth | BCG Med-Lines: Greek GDP grows from 125 billion euros in 2000 to a forecast 198 billion euros in 2008 (58% total growth), which passenger ticket volume tracks closely. |
| Capacity and utilization | Peak versus off-peak occupancy, physical space tradeoffs, and regulatory minimums | BCG Med-Lines: A 600-passenger ferry runs at 90% occupancy in June, July, and August and 30% the rest of the year. The hull holds 100 cars or 20 trucks (1 truck equals 5 cars). |
| Pricing and contract share | Price caps, tier premiums, purchase probabilities, and operator revenue splits | BCG Med-Lines: Cafeteria prices are capped at 4 euros for a sandwich and 1 euro for a soda, and Med-Lines keeps only 20% of cafeteria sales under an external license. |
| Payback and ongoing cost | Baseline revenue, percentage lift, upfront capital by bucket, depreciation, and yearly operating cost | McKinsey Beautify: 1.3 billion euros in baseline revenue with a 10% first-year lift against 150 million euros in upfront investment and 10 million euros in yearly cost. |
Worked example 1: BCG's Med-Lines multi-document case
BCG's online practice case follows Med-Lines, a medium-sized ferry operator in Greece whose CEO wants to increase revenues. You receive five documents in stages, covering Greek tourism, port departures and arrivals, onboard revenue sources, three ferry types on the Athens to Crete route, and the global shipbuilding market. Here is how to work through the main calculations and build a recommendation from the packet.
First, size the market trend and map the route network from Documents 1 and 2. Greek GDP was 125 billion euros in 2000 and is forecast to reach 198 billion euros in 2008. Dividing 198 by 125 and subtracting 1 gives 58.4%, or about 58% total growth. Because ticket sales track GDP closely, an index starting at 100 in 2000 reaches roughly 158 in 2008. Summing departures (or arrivals) gives 10 million one-way tickets sold in 2007.
Four routing rules in Document 2 let you solve the exact traffic on each leg: all Rhodes routes go through Mykonos, Mykonos connects only to Athens and Rhodes, and all arrivals in Other ports come from Athens. Since Rhodes has 500K departures and 500K arrivals and connects only to Mykonos, the Mykonos-Rhodes leg carries 500K tickets each way. Subtracting those 500K from Mykonos's 3,000K total arrivals leaves 2.5 million tickets from Athens to Mykonos (and 2.5 million back). Crete connects only to Athens (1.5 million Crete to Athens, 1.3 million Athens to Crete), and Other connects only to Athens (500K Other to Athens, 700K Athens to Other).
Applying the one-way ticket prices from Question 9 gives total 2007 passenger ticket revenue:
- Mykonos-Rhodes and Rhodes-Mykonos: (500K + 500K) times 10 euros = 10 million euros.
- Athens-Mykonos and Mykonos-Athens: (2,500K + 2,500K) times 20 euros = 100 million euros.
- Athens-Crete, Crete-Athens, Athens-Other, and Other-Athens: (1,300K + 1,500K + 700K + 500K) times 30 euros = 120 million euros.
- Total 2007 ticket revenue: 10 million + 100 million + 120 million = 230 million euros.
Worked example 1 continued: Unit economics, fleet choice and M&A
Document 3 breaks down the three revenue streams on a typical small ferry (600-passenger capacity: 500 deck and 100 cabin). In June, July, and August, occupancy hits 90%, or 540 passengers. All 100 cabin tickets sell out at 1.5 times the deck price, leaving 440 deck passengers. By our calculation from the Document 3 ratios, deck revenue (440 times 1) to cabin revenue (100 times 1.5 = 150) is 440 to 150, a ratio of 2.9 to 1.
In the cafeteria, prices are regulated at 4 euros for a sandwich and 1 euro for a soda. On an average trip, 50% of passengers buy a sandwich and a soda (5 euros), 30% buy only a soda (1 euro), and 20% buy nothing (0 euros). Expected spend per passenger is (0.50 times 5) + (0.30 times 1) + (0.20 times 0) = 2.80 euros. On a summer trip with 540 passengers, cafeteria sales total 540 times 2.80 euros = 1,512 euros. Because the cafeteria is licensed to an external operator and Med-Lines gets only 20% of sales, and because food prices cannot be raised without government approval, renegotiating the operator contract is the clearest way to lift Med-Lines' food and drink revenue.
For vehicles, the hull holds 100 passenger cars at 20 euros each or 20 commercial trucks (each truck takes the space of 5 cars). When a truck ticket costs 10 times a car ticket (200 euros), filling the hull with cars yields 2,000 euros per trip, filling it with trucks yields 4,000 euros, and a 60% car / 40% truck space split (60 cars and 8 trucks) yields (60 times 20) + (8 times 200) = 2,800 euros.
Document 4 compares three ferry types on the Athens-Crete route in 2007. Ferry Type 1 ran 200 round-trips, carried 320K passengers, and earned an indexed revenue of 100 (0.50 per trip, 0.3125 per thousand passengers). Ferry Type 2 ran 200 round-trips, carried 420K passengers, and earned 220 (1.10 per trip, 0.5238 per thousand passengers). Ferry Type 3 ran 300 round-trips, carried 270K passengers, and earned 150 (0.50 per trip, 0.5556 per thousand passengers). Type 3 earns the same revenue per trip as Type 1 (0.50) and the highest revenue per passenger. When Type 1 costs 100% more per trip than Type 3 and Type 2 costs 200% more per trip than Type 3, Type 3 is the most profitable ferry per passenger.
Finally, Document 5 looks at expansion. Rather than ordering two new ferries while global shipyards are busy with merchant vessels for booming Asian economies, Med-Lines considers acquiring Italian Seaways on the Greece-Italy route. Unlike Med-Lines, whose occupancy drops from 90% in summer to 30% the rest of the year, Italian Seaways has steady year-round revenue (August is only about 20% above March), explained by long-term contracts with wholesale exporters of Italian winter fruits. Presenting this case means tying all five documents together: capture commercial truck and contract freight to smooth out winter troughs, renegotiate the 20% cafeteria split, favor Type 3 economics on the Crete leg, and watch airline and hydroplane competition.
Worked example 2: Investment payback and rural savings in McKinsey cases
In a live interview, you do the arithmetic on paper without a calculator and talk the interviewer through each step. Two official McKinsey practice cases, Beautify and Diconsa, show how to set up and present multi-step math clearly.
In the McKinsey case interview sample case Beautify, a prestige cosmetics company with 1.3 billion euros in revenue is considering training its department store beauty consultants to sell through virtual channels. Question 3 asks how many years it will take for the investment to turn profitable, defined as when cumulative incremental revenues exceed the cost of the project. Lay out the numbers from the prompt in three lines before you calculate:
- Incremental annual revenue: 10% of 1.3 billion euros = 130 million euros per year, starting in Year 1.
- Upfront Year 1 investments: 50 million euros in IT + 25 million euros in training + 50 million euros in remodeling department store counters + 25 million euros in inventory = 150 million euros total upfront outlay (with 5% annual depreciation noted on the 50 million euro IT investment, or 2.5 million euros per year).
- Ongoing yearly operating cost: 10 million euros per year, starting in Year 1.
- Year 1 comparison (our calculation from McKinsey's Beautify figures): Year 1 incremental revenue is 130 million euros against 150 million euros in upfront project spend plus 10 million euros in yearly cost (160 million euros total Year 1 outlay, or 162.5 million euros if IT depreciation is counted separately), leaving a net deficit of 30 million euros at the end of Year 1. In Year 2, adding another 130 million euros of incremental revenue against 10 million euros of yearly cost adds 120 million euros in net gain, pushing cumulative incremental revenue well past cumulative project costs during Year 2.
Worked example 2 continued: Segmenting a population in McKinsey's Diconsa case
McKinsey's Diconsa practice case shows why you should segment a population on paper before multiplying. The Mexican government operates 22,000 Diconsa stores serving rural communities, and the team is evaluating whether families can collect state benefit payments at local stores instead of traveling to distant bank branches.
Question 2 gives six inputs: Mexico's population is 140 million, 20% is rural, half of the rural population receives state benefits, average family size is 4, a family currently spends 50 pesos per month in transportation and food to collect benefits, and collecting at Diconsa stores reduces that cost by 30% for the 60% of rural families living furthest from a bank branch and by 20% for the 40% living closer. Walk your interviewer through the chain one step at a time:
- Step 1 (Number of rural individuals receiving benefits): 140 million times 20% rural = 28 million rural residents. Half receive benefits = 14 million people.
- Step 2 (Number of benefit-receiving families): 14 million people divided by 4 members per family = 3.5 million families.
- Step 3 (Current annual cost per family): 50 pesos per month times 12 months = 600 pesos per family per year.
- The blended savings rate is (0.60 times 30%) + (0.40 times 20%) = 18% + 8% = 26% of current spend, or 156 pesos per family per year.
- Step 5 (Total annual savings across all rural families): 3.5 million families times 156 pesos per year = 546 million pesos saved per year (comprising 378 million pesos for the 2.1 million furthest families and 168 million pesos for the 1.4 million closer families).
Rules for calculators, notes and AI during your case
Tool rules depend on which case format you are taking. In McKinsey's live problem-solving interviews, calculators are not allowed. You write out your calculations on paper and talk your interviewer through your steps so they can follow your logic. In BCG's 45-minute online case, you may use scratch paper and a basic calculator, but no spreadsheets or other calculating tools. BCG's practice booklet scores the test at +3 points for each correct answer, 0 points for an unanswered question, and -1 point for an incorrect answer, so you should skip a question that takes too long rather than guess blindly.
Both firms encourage using AI tools before the interview to prepare. McKinsey states on its interviewing page that asking AI to explain concepts or frameworks and practicing interview questions with AI are encouraged, while using AI during assessments or generating real-time answers during an interview is not allowed. For virtual interviews, McKinsey asks candidates to use a quiet space, keep pen and paper within reach, turn the camera on with virtual backgrounds and blurring disabled, and disable any previously installed AI note-taking tools or virtual assistants.
Checklist for presenting your case recommendation
Whether you are summarizing a 30-minute live conversation or answering the final questions of a multi-document packet, use a consistent five-step checklist built by our team to keep your presentation tight. You can also practice delivering your synthesis alongside your behavioral interview stories so your pacing stays natural across the whole round.
- 1. State the decision in your first sentence: Say what the client should do (for example, launch the virtual advisor program, or renegotiate the cafeteria contract and shift Crete capacity toward Type 3 ferries) before you explain how you got there.
- 2. Name the two or three numbers that prove it: Quote the exact figures from your work, such as the 230 million euro ticket baseline, the 2.80 euro per-passenger food spend, or the Year 2 payback threshold.
- 3. Call out the segment difference: Point out where averages hide the real story, such as 90% summer versus 30% winter ferry occupancy, or the 30% versus 20% cost reduction between remote and nearby rural families.
- 4. Flag the main risk in the data: Name the assumption or external threat that could break the plan, such as hydroplane entrants on the Athens-Crete route, losing in-store shoppers to competing beauty brands, or fraud and low banking familiarity in rural stores.
- 5. Give the immediate next step: Tell the client what to test or negotiate first, and stop speaking so the interviewer can ask follow-up questions.
Practice a case out loud with Soreno
Reading a worked case shows you the steps, but in a real interview you have to structure the problem, read the exhibits, and present your math out loud while the interviewer pushes back. Practice a case free, no sign-up right in your browser.
From BCG: Case Interview Preparation, BCG: Consulting Interview Process, BCG: Online Case Practice Booklet (Med-Lines, 2019), McKinsey: Interviewing and Getting Ready for Your Interviews, McKinsey: Beautify Practice Case and McKinsey: Diconsa Practice Case.
1 practice question and sample answer
Say your answer out loud first, then read the sample answer.
Practice question
You have just completed the analysis for the CEO of Med-Lines based on the five BCG case documents. Present a 60-second executive recommendation on how Med-Lines should grow its revenue.
Sample answer. Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. To grow revenue above our 230 million euro passenger ticket baseline, I recommend a three-part plan focused on commercial contracts, onboard food share, and high-yield fleet deployment. First, we should pursue an acquisition of Italian Seaways rather than ordering two new ferries. Our Aegean fleet drops from 90% occupancy in the summer to 30% for the other nine months, whereas Italian Seaways keeps March and August trip revenues within 20% of each other through winter fruit export contracts. Second, we should renegotiate our external cafeteria contract. Passengers spend an average of 2.80 euros per trip, generating 1,512 euros on a typical summer crossing, but regulated prices prevent menu hikes and our current license leaves us with only 20% of sales. Third, on the Athens to Crete route, we should prioritize Type 3 ferries, which match Type 1 revenue per trip at half the operating cost, and fill hull space with commercial trucks, which double vehicle deck revenue from 2,000 euros to 4,000 euros per full load. Our next step is auditing Italian Seaways' freight contracts and hydroplane competition on the Crete leg.
It opens with the decision and the 230 million euro baseline, supports each of the three levers with exact numbers from the five case documents, addresses the winter seasonality gap, and ends with a concrete next step.
Practice the case interview, out loud
Soreno's AI interviewer runs a full case one question at a time, checks your math and scores your structure, any time you have 30 minutes.
Questions people ask
What is a presentation case in a consulting interview?
In consulting, a presentation case is a problem-solving interview or multi-document case assessment where you analyze a business challenge and present a structured recommendation. At McKinsey and BCG, this includes live conversational case interviews as well as timed document-based cases like BCG's 45-minute, 20-plus-question online case.
How should I structure a case study presentation?
McKinsey and BCG advise taking time to organize your thoughts and developing an overall logical approach before diving into granular details. Instead of forcing a standard memorized framework, listen carefully to the prompt, clarify assumptions, and group your points around the specific issues the client faces.
Can I use a calculator during a consulting case interview?
In McKinsey problem-solving interviews, calculators are not allowed. you work with pen and paper and talk the interviewer through your math steps. In BCG's 45-minute online practice case, a basic calculator and scratch paper are allowed, while spreadsheets are not.
Is there one right answer in a consulting presentation case?
No. Both BCG and McKinsey state on their careers pages that live case interviews do not always have a single right answer, and that interviewers focus on how you approach the problem and the quality of your reasoning. Written multiple-choice assessments like BCG's online case do have a single correct answer per question.
Can I use AI to prepare for a consulting case interview?
Yes. McKinsey explicitly encourages candidates to use AI to practice interview questions, polish resumes, and explain concepts or frameworks during preparation, while prohibiting AI use during live interviews or assessments.
More guides
- Consulting Presentation Slides: Structure, Charts & Build
- FTI Consulting Salary: Filings, Benchmarks & Pay (2026)
- Management Consulting Slide Deck: Structure and Guide
- CaseBasix Alternatives for Case Interview Prep (2026)
- Consulting Firm Hierarchy: Ranks at McKinsey, BCG and Bain
- Consulting Strategy Group: Services, Pay, and Vetting
- Deloitte Discovery Intern: How to Apply and Interview
- KPMG Verbal Reasoning Test: Format, Example and Prep
- Marketing and Strategy Consulting Firms Guide (2026)
- McKinsey & Company Strategy Consulting: Work, Cases & Pay
- Accenture Tech Consulting: Services, Roles & Interviews
- BCG Matrix: Boston Consulting Group Growth Matrix Guide