NERA Case Interview: Economic Consulting Guide and Worked Case

A NERA case interview evaluates your ability to structure economic and quantitative problems, test causal hypotheses, and defend empirical conclusions. Instead of applying general corporate business frameworks, economic consulting focuses on data-driven issues such as securities valuation, regulatory risk, benchmarking analysis, and litigation damages, as shown in official economist research records from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. You can practice a case free, no sign-up, before reading our full preparation guide and worked case below.

Updated

What NERA Economic Consulting Does and How It Shapes Your Interview

NERA Economic Consulting specializes in applying economic, financial, and quantitative analysis to complex litigation, regulatory disputes, and policy questions. In these engagements, every data point and assumption must withstand intense scrutiny from opposing experts and regulatory authorities.

You can see the exact analytical themes the firm addresses in the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission profile for Division of Economic and Risk Analysis economist Ignacio Franceschelli, who spent a decade at NERA's Securities and Finance Practice advancing from Consultant to Senior Consultant and Associate Director. The research, working papers, and industry presentations documented in that SEC record highlight the core analytical challenges NERA economists tackle.

These documented matters include assessing how benchmark interest rate shifts such as the LIBOR transition affect consumer mortgage contracts, evaluating student loan servicing quality using Consumer Financial Protection Bureau complaint data, modeling manufactured defaults and credit default swaps, and evaluating the role of punitive damages in mass torts litigation. Other core projects in the SEC record address statistical sampling defenses in class action suits, cryptocurrency regulatory and litigation risks, prepayment penalty securities valuation, and the analytical use and misuse of benchmarking methods.

When you interview at NERA, you are being tested on your microeconomic fundamentals, your grasp of counterfactual reasoning, and your ability to isolate causal variables within noisy empirical data. If you are also preparing for general management roles, compare this quantitative approach with our McKinsey case interview guide and BCG case interview guide to see how strategy cases differ.

How Economic Cases Differ from Strategy Cases

A general strategy case usually asks how a company can enter a new market, launch a product, or turn around a drop in profitability. In contrast, an economic consulting case asks how to measure economic impact, establish an empirical baseline, or test whether an observed price shift was caused by anticompetitive conduct or an outside market shock.

As BCG notes on its case interview preparation page, problem-solving interviews present candidates with realistic challenges where they must structure an approach, ask thoughtful questions, analyze data, perform calculations, and identify core drivers. Both McKinsey and BCG state that there is not always one single right or predetermined solution. What matters most is how you approach the problem, how you handle facts and data, and the quality of your underlying reasoning.

McKinsey's interviewing guidance also emphasizes listening carefully and developing solutions specific to the situation rather than forcing memorized, standard frameworks onto the prompt. In economic consulting, this means building your approach around formal microeconomic relationships, accounting identities, and econometric logic.

How an economic consulting case compares to a strategy case (our team's prep comparison)

How an economic consulting case compares to a strategy case (our team's prep comparison)
FeatureEconomic Consulting Case (such as NERA)Strategy Consulting Case (such as McKinsey or BCG)
Core questionHow much economic harm occurred, whether conduct caused an observed price shift, or how to value an assetHow to grow market share, launch a new product, or reverse a profit drop
Framework styleCounterfactual modeling (comparing the actual world to the but-for world), cost pass-through, and regression logicBusiness drivers such as revenue, variable and fixed costs, customer segments, and capabilities
Quantitative focusIsolating confounding variables, contribution margins (excluding fixed overhead), and empirical elasticityMarket sizing estimates, break-even unit volumes, and reading corporate business exhibits
Experience and fitIn-depth defense of your thesis, econometrics coursework, data cleaning methods, and teamwork under deadlinesPersonal impact, entrepreneurial drive, inclusive leadership, and client collaboration

Core Economic Consulting Concepts You Need to Know

To perform well in an economic consulting interview, you must be comfortable applying standard microeconomic and quantitative tools out loud without relying on buzzwords. Interviewers look for precise definitions and clear mathematical formulations.

Make sure you can define and apply these four foundational concepts during your case discussions:

  • 1. The But-For World (Counterfactual Analysis). The central question in litigation economics is measuring what would have happened to prices, volume, or profit in the absence of the alleged conduct or external shock. A simple before-and-after comparison is rarely enough because outside market conditions often change at the same time.
  • 2. Benchmarking and Control Groups. When historical data alone cannot isolate an effect, economists compare the affected entity to an unaffected yardstick or benchmark market that faced similar supply and demand conditions but was untouched by the alleged event.
  • 3. Lost Profits vs. Gross Revenue. When estimating damages from lost sales volume, you must compute lost contribution margin (revenue minus avoidable variable costs). Fixed overhead costs that the firm incurred regardless of volume must not be deducted, and gross revenue must never be treated as pure lost profit.
  • 4. Confounding Variables and Omitted Variable Bias. Before concluding that a specific event caused an observed change in price or quantity, you must check for alternative explanations such as raw material cost spikes, macroeconomic shifts, regulatory changes, or capacity constraints.

How to Solve an Economic Case Step by Step

When your interviewer delivers an economic consulting prompt, keep your structure organized around causal drivers and empirical measurement. You can practice structuring open-ended business problems in our consulting case study examples.

Follow these five steps to work through the scenario logically:

  • 1. Clarify the objective and the economic metric. Ask two or three questions to define the time horizon, the specific market or product boundary, and the exact metric required (such as price overcharge, lost profits, or asset valuation).
  • 2. Formulate your baseline or counterfactual. State clearly how you propose to model the but-for world. Explain whether you will use an unaffected historical baseline, an external benchmark group, or a cost-plus economic model.
  • 3. Identify and isolate confounding factors. List the outside forces that could have influenced your metric during the period in question. Mention raw material input costs, labor supply changes, general market inflation, and customer demand shifts.
  • 4. Walk through the calculations out loud with units. State your equation before substituting numbers. Maintain explicit units (dollars per unit, basis points, or thousands of units) and explain the economic intuition behind each calculation.
  • 5. State your recommendation, primary risk, and next empirical test. Deliver your numerical conclusion first. Follow up by identifying the assumption that carries the greatest uncertainty and describe what additional dataset you would test to verify it.

Worked Example: Benchmarking and Damages in a Component Dispute

Below is an original practice case written by our team to illustrate how benchmarking and counterfactual calculations operate in an economic consulting case. The company names and data are invented for practice.

The prompt: Your client is legal counsel representing Apex Auto, an automobile manufacturer. In 2024 and 2025, Apex purchased 500,000 engine sensors per year from a component supplier, VoltCorp, at a contracted price of $40 per sensor. Apex alleges that VoltCorp engaged in unlawful price-fixing with competing sensor manufacturers throughout those two years. In 2023, prior to the alleged price-fixing agreement, Apex bought identical sensors from VoltCorp at $30 per sensor. Apex's legal team initially claims damages of $10 per sensor, totaling $10,000,000 across the 1,000,000 sensors purchased during 2024 and 2025. How would you evaluate whether $10,000,000 represents an accurate estimate of economic damages?

Step 1: Set up the counterfactual structure. A direct comparison between the pre-period price ($30) and the post-period price ($40) assumes that sensor production costs and market demand remained completely static between 2023 and 2025. To determine the true but-for price, you must ask whether legitimate industry-wide cost shocks or technological specification changes occurred during that same window.

Step 2: Request data and isolate outside cost shifts. When you ask about industry cost conditions, the interviewer explains that sensor specifications did not change, but a global shortage of refined semiconductor silicon increased raw material costs across the entire sensor industry in early 2024. In an unaffected overseas geographic market where no price-fixing occurred, benchmark sensor prices rose from $30 in 2023 to $34 in 2024 and 2025 solely due to this input cost inflation.

Step 3: Compute the adjusted economic overcharge. Using the unaffected overseas market as a reliable yardstick, the counterfactual (but-for) price that Apex would have paid in 2024 and 2025 without unlawful conduct was $34 per sensor, not $30. Because Apex actually paid $40 per sensor, the true economic overcharge attributable to price coordination is $40 minus $34 = $6 per sensor.

Step 4: Calculate total overcharge damages. Over the two-year period, Apex purchased 500,000 sensors annually, totaling 1,000,000 sensors. Multiplying 1,000,000 sensors by the $6 per unit overcharge yields direct economic damages of $6,000,000. You should also note a potential secondary effect: if Apex passed part of this $6 component cost increase along to vehicle buyers, higher car prices may have reduced vehicle sales volume, creating potential lost contribution margin on unsold vehicles.

Step 5: Synthesize your conclusion. State your findings directly: By our calculation from the case data, the direct economic damages from the overcharge are $6,000,000, rather than the $10,000,000 initially claimed. While sensor prices increased by $10 overall, $4 of that increase was driven by an industry-wide silicon supply shock observed in unaffected benchmark markets. That leaves a net overcharge of $6 per unit across 1,000,000 units. To refine this estimate, my next step would be to verify whether VoltCorp and the overseas benchmark suppliers faced identical silicon supply contracts and energy tariffs.

Summary of our worked damages calculation (invented practice case data)

Summary of our worked damages calculation (invented practice case data)
Metric2023 Baseline2024 to 2025 Actual2024 to 2025 Benchmark (But-For)Net Economic Overcharge
Price per sensor$30$40$34 (includes $4 silicon cost shock)$6 per sensor ($40 - $34)
Two-year purchase volumeN/A1,000,000 units1,000,000 units1,000,000 units
Total financial expenditureN/A$40,000,000 actual paid$34,000,000 expected spend$6,000,000 net overcharge damages
How to Defend Your Research and Handle Data Stress Tests

Economic consulting interviews place heavy emphasis on your past analytical and empirical work. Interviewers frequently conduct in-depth reviews of your undergraduate thesis, capstone project, master's paper, or quantitative internship assignments. They want to see whether you truly understand your data choices, regression models, and potential sources of bias.

You can prepare for these discussions the way McKinsey suggests preparing for personal experience and technical interviews: select two or three analytical projects you know thoroughly, understand your specific role in building the models, and lead with your reasoning rather than a list of tasks. Rehearse your personal and project narratives out loud using our behavioral interview practice page.

During these discussions, an economist interviewer will often stress-test your empirical results with challenging follow-up questions. Here is how to handle three of the most common econometric challenges:

  • 1. Omitted Variable Bias: If an interviewer asks what happens to your estimated coefficient if an unobserved factor is correlated with both your independent variable and your outcome, explain the direction of the bias clearly. State whether your estimate overstates or understates the true effect and suggest a proxy variable or fixed-effects approach to control for it.
  • 2. Reverse Causality and Endogeneity: If asked whether variable Y might actually be causing variable X rather than the other way around, explain the timing of your data and discuss whether an instrumental variable, natural experiment, or difference-in-differences setup could help establish the direction of causality.
  • 3. Sample Selection Bias: When asked how missing data or non-random participation affects your findings, state plainly which segment of the population is underrepresented and discuss whether your conclusions apply only to that sub-sample or can be generalized.
14-Day Preparation Plan for Your Economic Consulting Interview

Our team developed this two-week checklist to help you balance microeconomic review, counterfactual problem-solving, and empirical research defense.

  • Refresh your understanding of supply and demand curves, price elasticity of demand, cost pass-through rates, and the distinction between marginal, variable, and fixed costs.
  • Focus on defining the but-for world, identifying valid control groups, and separating outside cost shocks from conduct-driven effects.
  • Days 7 to 9: Drill mental arithmetic and table interpretation. Practice computing percentage changes, weighted averages, and contribution margins cleanly on paper without external tools.
  • Write a one-page summary for each quantitative project on your resume, detailing the core question, data source, identification strategy, main coefficients, key limitations, and robustness checks.
  • Days 13 to 14: Conduct full 30-minute mock interviews out loud. Practice articulating your opening structures, narrating calculations, and delivering concise conclusions with next steps.

From U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission: DERA Economist Biography of Ignacio Franceschelli, BCG Careers: Case Study Interview Preparation, BCG Careers: Consulting Interview Process and McKinsey & Company: Interviewing and Case Preparation.

1 practice question and sample answer

Say your answer out loud first, then read the sample answer.

Practice question

  1. Walk me through a quantitative research paper or data project on your resume. What was your main finding, what was the biggest limitation in your data, and how did you test whether that limitation biased your conclusion?

    Sample answer. Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. "For my senior thesis, I studied whether a municipal congestion fee reduced commercial delivery traffic in a downtown commercial district. I compared hourly camera traffic counts inside the charging zone against an outer control perimeter over the six months before and six months after the policy took effect. My initial difference-in-differences regression indicated a 14% reduction in delivery vehicle volume inside the zone. The primary limitation was that a major downtown river bridge closed for scheduled structural maintenance during the fourth month of the policy, which could have diverted commercial traffic independently of the toll. To test whether this bridge closure distorted my estimate, I re-estimated the model excluding the maintenance period and checked traffic volumes across corridors that do not feed that bridge. The measured reduction shifted from 14% to 11% and remained statistically significant, confirming that the toll fee itself accounted for approximately 11 percentage points of the decline while the detour explained the remaining 3 percentage points."

    The answer establishes the research question immediately, specifies the empirical identification strategy (a difference-in-differences comparison with an outer control group), highlights a distinct confounding factor (the bridge closure), and outlines the specific robustness check executed to isolate the true causal effect.

Practice the case interview, out loud

Soreno's AI interviewer runs a full case one question at a time, checks your math and scores your structure, any time you have 30 minutes.

Questions people ask

Is there a single right answer in an economic consulting case interview?

No. Official consulting interview guidelines from firms like McKinsey and BCG state that there is not always one single right or logical answer. Interviewers focus primarily on how you structure ambiguous problems, how you interpret data, and the logical strength of your reasoning.

Should I use standard business frameworks like the 4Ps or 3Cs in a NERA case?

No. Management consulting guidelines advise candidates to listen carefully and build solutions suited to the specific problem rather than reciting memorized templates. In economic consulting, your structure should rely on microeconomic fundamentals, counterfactual analysis, and accounting identities.

What research topics do NERA economists work on?

Public SEC economist records documenting NERA practice experience show work on benchmark interest rate transitions, student loan servicing complaints, credit default swaps, statistical sampling in class actions, cryptocurrency risks, and punitive damages in mass torts.

How should I prepare for the quantitative research defense part of the interview?

Select two or three empirical projects from your resume and prepare to explain your research question, dataset, econometric specification, and potential biases. Be ready to explain how you tested for omitted variables, reverse causality, or measurement error.

Keep going