IT Consulting Cases: How to Prepare and Practice Out Loud

IT and technical consulting evaluations combine business case interviews with role-specific assessments in programming, data analysis, or system design, as stated on McKinsey's interviewing page. Rather than testing memorized frameworks, firms like McKinsey and BCG evaluate how you structure ambiguous business and technology problems, perform paper calculations without a calculator, and explain your reasoning step by step. You can practice a case free, no sign-up, to rehearse your structure and math out loud before your interview.

Updated

What IT Consulting Cases and Technical Assessments Test

When you apply for technology-focused or client-facing consulting roles, your evaluation tests both business problem-solving and technical capability. At BCG, technologists, scientists, programmers, engineers, and human-centered designers work in BCG X, the firm's tech and design unit, alongside general consulting teams across Digital, Technology, and Data capabilities such as cloud computing, cybersecurity, data and digital platforms, and AI.

At McKinsey, candidates applying for client-facing roles complete Personal Experience Interviews (PEI) and Problem-Solving Interviews, which the firm also calls case interviews. Depending on the role, you may also have an expertise interview so the firm can understand how your specific experience and skill set enable you to excel. If you apply for a technical role at McKinsey, your process may include a hands-on technical assessment and interview exercises focused on your technical knowledge, how you solve complex problems, and past experiences.

Across both firms, interviewers are not looking for a single right answer or a memorized checklist. McKinsey explicitly advises candidates to listen carefully and share tailored solutions rather than standard frameworks. BCG likewise states on its case interview preparation page that what matters most is how you approach the problem and the quality of your reasoning.

  • Problem-Solving Interview (Case Interview): Presents a realistic business scenario where you structure an approach, ask questions, analyze data, run calculations, and recommend a course of action.
  • Hands-On Technical Assessment: Used for technical roles at McKinsey to test programming, data analysis, system design, or other role-specific technical tasks.
  • Technical Role Conversations and Practical Exercises: Live discussions evaluating your technical strengths and how you develop solutions to complex problems.
  • Expertise Interview: Offered for specialized roles at McKinsey to assess how your past experience and technical skill set fit the position.
  • Skills and Team Interviews: Part of BCG's 4-step consulting interview process (Application, Skills Interview, Case Interview, and Team Interview) assessing experience, motivation, analytical skills, and communication.

Official Technical and Case Evaluation Formats at McKinsey and BCG

Official Technical and Case Evaluation Formats at McKinsey and BCG
Evaluation StageFirmWhat It CoversOfficial Preparation Guidance
Hands-on Technical AssessmentMcKinseyProgramming, data analysis, system design, or role-specific technical tasksReview role-tailored information and the Candidate Preparation Booklet shared by your recruiter
Problem-Solving / Case InterviewMcKinsey & BCGStructuring a realistic business problem, analyzing data, quick calculations, identifying key factorsAvoid standard frameworks, think structurally, write calculations on paper, and show your thinking out loud
Technical Conversations & Expertise InterviewMcKinseyPractical exercises, technical knowledge, and how your skill set enables success in the roleBe ready to share specific examples from past experiences and how you approach complex problems
Skills Interview & Personal Experience Interview (PEI)BCG & McKinseyPast accomplishments, challenges, motivation, and specific actions you tookPrepare two personal examples per PEI area at McKinsey. lead with reasoning and avoid rehearsed stories

Core Reasoning and Communication Steps in a Case

Whether your case involves launching a virtual channel for retail staff, designing an enterprise platform, or evaluating a new product, the core analytical sequence remains the same. BCG defines your task in a case study interview in five concrete parts: structure your approach, ask thoughtful questions, analyze data, perform quick calculations, and identify the most important factors.

InMcKinsey's published Electro-Light practice case, the firm provides stage-by-stage hints on how to execute these steps during a live conversation. Before you answer the first question, write down important information as the interviewer presents the scenario and ask the interviewer to explain anything that is not clear.

Next, take time to organize your thoughts and develop an overall approach before diving into details. When the case moves to quantitative analysis, do not rush. Calculators are not allowed in McKinsey case interviews. Write out your calculations on paper and talk your interviewer through your steps so they can follow your organized approach and help you if needed. When asked to brainstorm how a client can achieve a target, group your thoughts around the specific issues raised in the question so your answers stay relevant.

  • Do listen actively, think structurally, and communicate clearly throughout the session.
  • Do clarify assumptions and show your thinking as you work through each branch of the problem.
  • Do group your ideas around the client's specific constraints rather than reciting generic lists.
  • Don't panic under pressure or rush your response before organizing an overall approach.
  • Don't overcomplicate solutions, ignore feedback from the interviewer, stay silent during math, or interrupt.

How to Structure Common IT and Digital Case Scenarios

Because McKinsey and BCG advise against forcing standard frameworks onto a prompt, you should build your structure directly from the client's objective and technology constraints. For example, one of McKinsey's five official practice cases, Beautify, asks whether a global beauty products company should train in-store beauty consultants in the effective use of virtual channels to connect with customers. Solving a digital channel or system design prompt like that requires splitting the problem into custom buckets that test business value, technical feasibility, and operational adoption.

When you build a tailored structure for an IT or technology case, organize your buckets so they answer the specific decision the executive faces. Below are three tailored ways our team structures common technology and digital problem prompts without relying on memorized jargon.

  • Digital Channel or Tool Rollout (such as virtual customer channels): Split into Customer Demand and Revenue Uplift (adoption rate, basket size, retention), Training and Technology Costs (platform licensing or build cost, training hours per employee, ongoing support), and Operational Risks (channel conflict with physical stores, staff readiness, service quality).
  • System Design or Build-vs-Buy Decisions: Split into Technical and Functional Fit (performance requirements, integration with existing data platforms, security), Total Financial Impact (upfront engineering or vendor implementation costs, ongoing run-rate maintenance, payback window), and Execution Capability (engineering headcount, timeline to launch, vendor lock-in).
  • Product or Technology Investment (such as McKinsey's Talbot Trucks electric truck case or Electro-Light launch): Split into Market Attractiveness (customer segment size, willingness to pay, competitor shares), Unit Economics and Break-Even (price per unit, variable cost per unit, upfront fixed capital and marketing costs), and Supply Chain and Technical Readiness (plant capacity, production process changes, distribution network).

Worked Example: Cloud Platform Migration and Break-Even Math

To see how paper math and out-loud communication work together in an IT case, review the worked calculation below. This is an original practice scenario written by our team, modeled on the break-even and unit-cost logic tested in McKinsey's Electro-Light sample case. The client and numbers are invented for practice.

Prompt: Northstar Logistics runs an on-premise order-tracking database that costs $18 million per year to operate. The CIO is considering migrating to a cloud platform. The cloud vendor charges $0.12 per order processed, whereas the current variable processing cost is $0.20 per order on legacy servers. However, migrating requires $12 million in upfront fixed integration and training costs, and annual fixed cloud administration costs will be $14 million per year. Northstar processes 50 million orders per year. How many years will it take for the cloud migration to break even, and at what annual order volume would Northstar break even in exactly 1 year?

Step 1: Organize your approach out loud. Tell the interviewer you will first calculate the annual fixed cost savings and the per-order variable savings at the current volume of 50 million orders, sum them to find total annual net savings, and divide the $12 million upfront migration cost by the annual savings to find the payback period.

Step 2: Calculate annual savings at 50 million orders on paper. Current fixed server cost is $18 million and new fixed cloud administration cost is $14 million, which yields $4 million per year in fixed cost savings. On the variable side, cost per order drops from $0.20 to $0.12, saving $0.08 per order. Across 50 million orders, $0.08 times 50 million equals $4 million per year in variable savings. Total annual savings equal $4 million fixed plus $4 million variable, or $8 million per year.

Step 3: Compute the payback period and the 1-year break-even volume. Dividing the $12 million upfront migration cost by $8 million in annual savings gives a break-even timeline of 1.5 years (18 months). To break even in exactly 1 year, total annual savings must equal the $12 million upfront cost. Since fixed savings already provide $4 million in Year 1, variable savings must cover the remaining $8 million. Dividing $8 million by $0.08 saved per order shows Northstar would need 100 million orders in Year 1 (double its current volume) to pay back the migration in a single year.

  • Official math parallel: In Question 2 of McKinsey's Electro-Light case, Electro-Light launches in a 16-ounce format (one-eighth of a gallon) at a price of $2 to retailers, with an estimated $1.90 per bottle cost to produce and deliver and $40 million in total fixed costs. By our calculation from McKinsey's Electro-Light case, subtracting $1.90 from $2 gives a $0.10 margin per bottle, requiring 400 million bottles ($40 million divided by $0.10) to break even.
  • Always label your units on paper (orders, bottles, dollars per unit, millions per year) so you never mix unit margins with annual fixed overhead.
  • State what the number means for the client right after you compute it, rather than waiting for the interviewer to ask.

A Concrete Checklist to Practice IT Cases Out Loud

Reading sample cases silently builds familiarity, but interviews are live conversations where you are graded on how clearly you communicate and show your thinking. Use this 5-step rehearsal checklist written by our team to turn official resources into out-loud practice.

  • Step 1: Run McKinsey's Beautify and Electro-Light sample cases with a timer. Read the prompt, close the suggested answer, take time to organize your thoughts on paper, and speak your opening structure out loud.
  • Step 2: Practice paper-only arithmetic while speaking every step. Take a break-even or unit-cost problem, put away your calculator, write each equation cleanly on paper, and narrate why you are multiplying or dividing each figure.
  • Step 3: Complete BCG's free job simulation, OneDay@BCG, on BCG's case interview preparation page to see the types of daily challenges consultants work through.
  • Step 4: Prepare two detailed personal examples for each of McKinsey's four Personal Experience Interview areas, plus technical project examples if you are applying for a technical or expertise role. Practice telling them conversationally, leading with your reasoning rather than a rehearsed script.
  • Step 5: Rehearse a full interactive case out loud with an AI interviewer or practice partner that pushes back on your assumptions. You can practice a case free, no sign-up, or see a real sample report on Soreno to check how your structure, math, and communication hold up under follow-up questions.
Rules for Using AI in Prep and Setting Up Virtual Interviews

If you use AI tools while preparing for technical or consulting interviews, follow the firm's official integrity rules. On its interviewing page, McKinsey states that it equips its own people with proprietary AI tools like Lilli and ChatGPT Enterprise, and it encourages candidates to use AI responsibly during preparation. Specifically, McKinsey lists three encouraged uses and three prohibited uses in its hiring process.

When your interview takes place virtually, your setup must also comply with assessment integrity rules. McKinsey instructs candidates to disable any previously installed AI software, such as note-taking tools or virtual assistants, before the call begins because those programs may unintentionally record or assist with the interview.

  • Encouraged by McKinsey: Asking AI to explain concepts or frameworks as part of your prep.
  • Encouraged by McKinsey: Practicing interview questions with AI.
  • Encouraged by McKinsey: Polishing your resume.
  • Not Allowed by McKinsey: Generating real-time answers during an interview.
  • Not Allowed by McKinsey: Using AI during assessments (unless specifically permitted).
  • Not Allowed by McKinsey: Exaggerating or creating achievements that are not yours.
  • Virtual setup checklist: Choose a quiet, private space, wear headphones to minimize background noise, keep your laptop charger, pen, paper, and water within reach, keep your camera on, and do a test run to make sure virtual backgrounds or blurring features are disabled.

From McKinsey & Company: Interviewing at McKinsey, McKinsey & Company: Electro-Light Practice Case, Boston Consulting Group: Consulting Interview Process, Boston Consulting Group: Case Study Interview Preparation and Boston Consulting Group: Early Careers & BCG X.

1 practice question and sample answer

Say your answer out loud first, then read the sample answer.

Practice question

  1. A global retail company is evaluating whether to equip and train its in-store sales associates to use a new virtual clienteling platform to advise customers remotely (inspired by McKinsey's Beautify sample case). What key factors would you examine to help the CEO decide whether to roll out this technology?

    Sample answer. Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. "Before diving into the details, I would organize my approach into three areas to test whether rolling out the virtual platform creates net financial and strategic value. First, Customer Demand and Incremental Revenue: I want to check what share of our customers actually want virtual consultations, how much incremental spend or retention lift a virtual session generates, and whether online advising brings in new buyers or simply shifts sales that would have happened in the store anyway. Second, Technology and Training Economics: I would look at the upfront fixed costs to license or build the virtual platform and integrate it with our inventory and CRM systems, plus the variable cost of training store associates and paying for their time on virtual calls. Third, Store Operations and Execution: I would examine whether store staff have idle capacity during off-peak hours to handle virtual calls without hurting in-person customer service, and what incentives are needed so associates adopt the tool. I would like to start by sizing the incremental revenue per associate against the training and software cost to see the payback period."

    It follows McKinsey and BCG guidance by taking time to set an overall approach before diving into details, tailoring the three buckets directly to a virtual-channel technology rollout rather than naming a generic framework, and proposing a clear quantitative starting point.

Practice the case interview, out loud

Soreno's AI interviewer runs a full case one question at a time, checks your math and scores your structure, any time you have 30 minutes.

Questions people ask

What happens in a technical consulting assessment at McKinsey?

If you apply for a technical role at McKinsey, you may be invited to complete a hands-on technical assessment that tests programming, data analysis, system design, or other role-specific technical tasks. Your interviews may also include conversations, practical exercises, and an expertise interview focused on your technical knowledge, problem-solving approach, and past experiences.

Should I memorize standard IT frameworks for a consulting case interview?

No. McKinsey explicitly advises candidates to listen carefully and offer tailored solutions rather than standard frameworks because there is no single logical solution. BCG similarly states that there is not always a single right answer and that how you approach the problem and the quality of your reasoning matter most.

Are calculators allowed during technical or consulting case interviews?

In McKinsey Problem-Solving Interviews, calculators are not allowed. You should write out your calculations on paper during the interview and talk your interviewer through your steps out loud to demonstrate an organized approach.

Can I use AI to practice consulting case interviews?

Yes. McKinsey explicitly encourages using AI to practice interview questions, ask for explanations of concepts or frameworks, and polish your resume. However, generating real-time answers during an interview or using AI during an assessment (unless specifically permitted) is not allowed, and you must disable AI note-taking tools or virtual assistants before virtual interviews.

What is BCG X and how does BCG interview for consulting roles?

BCG X is the tech and design unit of BCG, where technologists, scientists, programmers, engineers, and human-centered designers build products and businesses. Across BCG's consulting interview process, candidates move through four steps: Application, Skills Interview, Case Interview, and Team Interview.

Keep going