EV Maker Growth Case: Strategy, TCO Math, and Worked Example

An EV maker growth case tests how a vehicle manufacturer scales electric production, lowers total cost of ownership (TCO), and adds software or charging revenue while funding the shift from combustion engines. According to BCG's automotive industry overview, the automotive sector contributes 12% of global emissions, and funding the transition from internal combustion engines to battery-electric vehicles can require multi-billion-dollar cost transformations, such as the $7 billion+ in cash and EBIT improvement BCG helped a European premium automaker achieve. In interviews, you solve this by comparing electric and combustion unit economics, sizing charging and supply chain bottlenecks, and building a clear growth plan.

Updated

What an EV maker growth case asks you to solve

In an electric vehicle case, the prompt usually centers on one of two clients. Either a legacy original equipment manufacturer (OEM) is funding its shift from internal combustion engines (ICE) to battery-electric vehicles (BEVs), or a pure-play EV entrant is scaling production, protecting margins, and expanding into new markets or services. BCG notes on its automotive industry overview page that it partners with new entrants to drive scale and differentiate in the ways that matter most, while working with traditional suppliers to refocus their portfolios as revenues from legacy components plateau.

You should also compare the two main EV growth archetypes: a top-down premium entrant using direct-to-consumer sales and a proprietary fast-charging network versus a battery-first vertical integrator entering at the mass-market low end before moving upmarket.

McKinsey and BCG use this setting to test how you handle technological disruption and unit economics. On McKinsey's interviewing page, the firm notes that problem-solving interviews do not have one logical solution, and asks candidates to listen carefully and share specific solutions rather than standard frameworks. BCG's case interview preparation guide explains that you work through the problem step by step: structure your approach, ask thoughtful questions, analyze data, perform quick calculations, and identify the most important factors while demonstrating business intuition and creativity.

You can practice a case free, no sign-up to test your structuring speed before reading the worked examples below, or see a real sample report to understand how interviewers grade your math and synthesis alongside other consulting case study examples.

  • Legacy OEM transition: Optimize R&D and cut material costs in the combustion business to fund new BEV platforms.
  • Commercial or passenger market entry: Find the price and total cost of ownership (TCO) an electric vehicle must hit so buyers switch from diesel or gasoline.
  • Revenue diversification: Supplement vehicle sales with recurring software subscriptions, autonomous fleet services, paid fast charging, and energy storage.
  • Capacity and supply chain scale-up: Ramp new production lines, localize battery cell and lithium refining, and handle tariff or tax-credit shifts.

McKinsey's official EV practice case: Talbot Trucks

The best-known official EV prompt is Talbot Trucks, one of five practice cases on McKinsey's careers site (alongside Beautify, Diconsa, Electro-Light, and Transforming a national education system). Talbot Trucks is a Europe-based private truck OEM and a leader in quality manufacturing that produces and sells trucks worldwide. Its primary customer base has two segments: large trucking companies that own thousands of trucks, and smaller owner-operators that own fewer trucks.

Trucks in the case are mainly powered by diesel engines using carbon-based petroleum fuel. The CEO asked McKinsey to assess the feasibility and attractiveness of investing in electric truck (eTruck) manufacturing for its European market to reduce its fleet's carbon footprint. Two core technological disruptions separate eTrucks from diesel trucks: powertrain design (e-motor and batteries versus combustion engines) and refueling speed (comparably slow charging versus quick refilling with diesel fuel at gas stations).

In a McKinsey case interview, the interviewer leads you through three specific questions. Calculators are not allowed in McKinsey problem-solving interviews, so write your calculations on paper and talk your interviewer through your steps.

  • Question 1 (Market attractiveness and feasibility): What information would you collect to understand the attractiveness for Talbot Trucks in producing and selling eTrucks in Europe? Organize an overall approach before diving into details: separate customer demand (large fleets vs. owner-operators), eTruck unit economics and manufacturing capability, European charging infrastructure, and regulatory rules.
  • Question 2 (Total Cost of Ownership inference): Compare the TCO for buying and operating one diesel truck versus one eTruck. McKinsey gives three facts: the 'Other' cost category includes tolls, insurances, and taxes. Diesel trucks cost €100,000 and have no residual value at the end of their lifetime. And there is a significant shortage of drivers in the market. Slower charging on an eTruck increases route time and driver hours per trip, which is a costly penalty when drivers are scarce.
  • Question 3 (Maximum eTruck price calculation): Focus groups with Talbot Trucks' customers show that the total cost of an eTruck must equal a diesel truck to be attractive. With a diesel truck priced at €100,000 and zero residual value, the maximum eTruck price is €100,000 plus lifetime operating savings (lower electricity, maintenance, tolls, and taxes) minus extra operating costs (additional driver wages or downtime from slower charging).

Worked example: EV TCO and break-even pricing math

Because public prompts hide the numerical exhibits, our team wrote a step-by-step worked example modeled on the commercial eTruck TCO and growth problem. All numbers below are our example data written for this page so you can practice the arithmetic out loud.

Prompt (our example): Apex Commercial sells a European diesel delivery van for €100,000 with a 5-year useful life and €0 residual value. Each van drives 60,000 km per year (300,000 km over 5 years). Management wants to launch an electric van (eVan). Customers will buy the eVan only if its 5-year TCO is equal to or lower than the diesel van. The eVan assembly line requires €180 million in upfront CapEx, and each eVan costs €76,000 in variable manufacturing and battery costs. What is the maximum eVan price, and how many units must Apex sell to break even on the factory investment?

Step 1 (Diesel 5-year TCO): Over 300,000 km, diesel fuel is €45,000 (300,000 km x €0.15/km). Maintenance is €25,000 (€5,000/yr x 5). Driver wages are €200,000 (€40,000/yr x 5). Other costs (tolls, insurance, and taxes) are €30,000 (€6,000/yr x 5). Total 5-year operating cost is €300,000. Adding the €100,000 purchase price gives a 5-year diesel TCO of €400,000.

Step 2 (eVan 5-year operating cost): Electricity is €24,000 (300,000 km x €0.08/km). Maintenance is €15,000 (€3,000/yr x 5). Slow charging and a driver shortage require extra driver waiting hours, raising 5-year wages to €215,000 (€43,000/yr x 5). Other costs drop to €20,000 (€4,000/yr x 5) from zero-emission toll exemptions. Total 5-year eVan operating cost is €274,000.

Step 3 (Max price and break-even volume): To match the €400,000 TCO, the maximum eVan purchase price is €400,000 minus €274,000, or €126,000. At a €126,000 price and €76,000 variable cost, contribution margin is €50,000 per unit. Dividing the €180 million factory CapEx by €50,000 gives a break-even volume of 3,600 eVans.

Step 4 (Operational scale-up, headcount, and cash runway math, our example): Suppose Apex targets 3,600 eVans in Year 1. If each eVan requires 400 assembly steps averaging 45 seconds per step, cycle time is 18,000 seconds, or 5 labor-hours per van. Producing 3,600 vans requires 18,000 labor-hours (3,600 x 5). At 1,800 working hours per worker per year, the assembly line needs 10 production workers. However, if each eVan uses a 100 kWh battery pack and raw material inflation pushes cell costs up by €50 per kWh, variable cost jumps by €5,000 per van (to €81,000), cutting unit contribution margin from €50,000 to €45,000 and raising the break-even volume to 4,000 eVans (€180M / €45,000). Finally, if Apex holds €45 million in working cash and pays €3 million per month in fixed factory overhead before deliveries begin, a 3-month production ramp delay burns €9 million in cash and cuts cash runway from 15 months to 12 months.

Worked example: 5-year TCO comparison (300,000 km lifetime, invented case data for practice)

Worked example: 5-year TCO comparison (300,000 km lifetime, invented case data for practice)
Cost categoryDiesel van (5-year total)Electric van (5-year total)eVan difference vs. diesel
Vehicle purchase price (zero residual value)€100,000€126,000 (max TCO-equal price)+€26,000
Fuel or electricity (300,000 km)€45,000 (€0.15/km)€24,000 (€0.08/km)-€21,000
Maintenance and repair€25,000 (€5,000/yr)€15,000 (€3,000/yr)-€10,000
Driver wages (including charging wait time)€200,000 (€40,000/yr)€215,000 (€43,000/yr)+€15,000
Other (tolls, insurance, and taxes)€30,000 (€6,000/yr)€20,000 (€4,000/yr)-€10,000
Total 5-year TCO€400,000€400,000€0

Five strategic pillars for an EV growth framework

When you build an opening structure in a BCG case interview, avoid generic buckets. BCG's automotive strategy overview highlights five themes shaping the industry: the transition to electric vehicles, software-defined vehicles, the power of AI, supply chain resilience, and business model innovation.

  • 1. ICE-to-BEV cost transformation: Legacy OEMs fund battery platforms from current operations. BCG enabled a European premium vehicle manufacturer to realize more than $7 billion in cash and EBIT improvement through a large-scale cost transformation while lowering material costs for new BEV platforms.
  • 2. Customer-centric charging strategy: Solving charge anxiety drives adoption. Ford Motor Company achieved record EV sales growth by partnering with BCG on the Ford Power Promise, a customer-centric strategy built to alleviate charge anxiety.
  • 3. Software-defined vehicles (SDVs) and R&D efficiency: Vehicles generate post-sale revenue through over-the-air updates and subscriptions. BCG helped a global automaker optimize the deployment of more than 10,000 engineers and more than €2 billion in annual R&D spend for its next generation of software-defined vehicles.
  • 4. AI-driven pricing and manufacturing: Auto AI by BCG X crunches micro-market data and uses machine learning to simulate how price changes affect sales volumes, inventory management, and volume allocation. BCG also helped a leading off-highway vehicle maker identify about $250 million in annual EBIT opportunity, cut engineering costs by 10%, and improve speed to market by up to 35%.
  • 5. Supply chain resilience and vertical integration: Check whether the automaker should localize battery cell assembly, refine its own lithium, or redesign components to reduce waste.

Real-world EV maker benchmarks from 2025-2026 SEC filings

Real industry numbers help you sanity-check market sizing and unit economics. The metrics below come from third-quarter 2026 earnings releases (ended September 30, 2026) from fast-charging operators EVgo and Blink Charging, alongside qualitative product and strategy disclosures from Tesla's Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2025.

  • Vehicle lineup and direct-to-consumer model: Per Tesla's 2025 Form 10-K, Tesla manufactures five consumer vehicles (Model 3, Y, S, X, and Cybertruck) plus the commercial Tesla Semi, selling directly through its website and company-owned stores while integrating batteries directly with vehicle body structures to optimize weight, range, and cost.
  • Software, Robotaxi, and energy storage: Per Tesla's 2025 Form 10-K, Tesla launched its autonomous Robotaxi ride-hailing service using Model Y vehicles, with plans to add its purpose-built Cybercab later alongside Full Self-Driving (Supervised) subscriptions. Tesla also sells Powerwall and Megapack lithium-ion energy storage systems managed by Autobidder and Powerhub software.
  • Charging network monetization: Per Tesla's 2025 Form 10-K, Tesla opens its Supercharger network to non-Tesla vehicles via NACS and sells hardware through Supercharger for Business. In Q3 2026, EVgo reported $91.4 million in total revenue, $71.8 million in charging network revenue (+29% YoY), 39.0% charging network gross margin, 5,530 stalls in operation (+20% YoY), over 1.9 million customer accounts, 103 GWh of network throughput (+8% YoY), and 283 kWh per stall in average daily throughput. By our calculation from EVgo's Q3 2026 Form 8-K, dividing $71,788 thousand in Q3 charging network revenue by 103 GWh (103,000,000 kWh) of network throughput equals about $0.70 in charging network revenue per kWh dispensed, and dividing $71,788 thousand by 5,530 ending stalls equals about $12,982 in quarterly charging revenue per stall.

EV and charging benchmarks from 2025-2026 SEC filings

EV and charging benchmarks from 2025-2026 SEC filings
Company and filingOperational metricFinancial metricStrategic growth lever cited
Tesla (FY 2025 Form 10-K, SEC.gov, Dec 31, 2025)5 consumer models (Model 3, Y, S, X, Cybertruck) plus Tesla Semi, Powerwall, and MegapackTwo reportable segments: (i) automotive and (ii) energy generation and storageAutonomous Robotaxi service, FSD (Supervised) subscriptions, Supercharger for Business, Cortex AI cluster
EVgo (Q3 2026 Form 8-K / Ex. 99.1, SEC.gov, Nov 9, 2026)5,530 stalls in operation (+20% YoY), 103 GWh throughput (+8% YoY), 283 kWh/day per stallTotal Q3 revenue $91.4M, charging network revenue $71.8M (+29% YoY), 39.0% charging network gross marginScaling NACS (290+ connectors as of Nov 6, 2026), grocery-anchored fast chargers, 750 kW architecture for 2027
Blink Charging (Q3 2026 Form 8-K / Ex. 99.1, SEC.gov, Nov 5, 2026)52 Blink-owned sites with EnergyConnect deployment, 21% demand fee reductionTotal Q3 revenue $18.4M, 26.3% GAAP gross margin (55.0% non-GAAP), $0.2M Adjusted EBITDAContract manufacturing transition (Jan 2026), targeting 80% recurring/repeatable revenue (at 55% in Q3)
Regulatory and policy risks to flag in your recommendation

Strong recommendations name the biggest risks to the thesis. EVgo's Q3 2026 earnings release highlights the enactment of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act of 2025, which addresses the termination of the Alternative Fuel Vehicle Refueling Property Credit (30C), though EVgo sold its 2025 portfolio of 30C income tax credits for $7.7 million net of transaction costs.

Always test whether your client's unit economics work without government tax credits or regulatory credit windfalls, and flag import tariffs, escalating trade wars, utility permitting delays, and autonomous vehicle regulations.

Step-by-step checklist to run an EV case in 30 minutes

Whether you are preparing for a Bain case interview, McKinsey, or BCG, use this five-step plan written by our team to keep your pacing tight.

  • Step 1 (Clarify objective and segment): Confirm whether the client is a legacy OEM or pure-play EV maker, the vehicle segment (passenger vs. commercial trucks), the geography, and the target metric (TCO parity, break-even volume, or EBIT).
  • Step 2 (Build a four-part structure): Split into (1) Market demand by segment, (2) Customer TCO and pricing power, (3) Manufacturing scale, battery supply chain, and CapEx, and (4) Ecosystem enablers (charging, software revenue, and regulations).
  • Step 3 (Run TCO and break-even math on paper): Write out every unit (euros per km, kWh per day, hours per vehicle) without a calculator. Rebuild the baseline combustion cost before calculating the EV difference.
  • Step 4 (Interpret exhibits and brainstorm growth levers): Tie charts to the buyer. Commercial fleets care about driver shortages and charging downtime. Retail buyers care about charge anxiety guarantees, insurance savings, and software upgrades.
  • Step 5 (Deliver an answer-first recommendation): State the decision and your exact price or volume number first, followed by two reasons, the top policy or charging risk, and the next step.
How McKinsey and BCG test EV cases and AI rules

Before live interviews, most McKinsey consulting applicants take Solve, a gamified assessment that requires no special preparation. BCG's process has four steps (Application, Skills Interview, Case Interview, and Team Interview), often starting with a cognitive test alongside consulting fit and behavioral questions.

McKinsey encourages using AI to practice interview questions and explain frameworks during prep, but strictly prohibits generating real-time answers during an interview or using AI during assessments unless permitted. Candidates must disable note-taking or virtual assistant software during virtual interviews. To practice out loud with pen and paper, practice a case free, no sign-up with Soreno's AI interviewer.

From McKinsey & Company: Talbot Trucks Practice Case, McKinsey & Company: Interviewing and AI in the Hiring Process, Boston Consulting Group: Case Interview Preparation, Boston Consulting Group: Consulting Interview Process, Boston Consulting Group: Application and Interviews at BCG Switzerland, Boston Consulting Group: Automotive Industry Consulting and Strategy, U.S. SEC: Tesla, Inc. Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2025, U.S. SEC: EVgo Inc. Q3 2026 Financial Results (Exhibit 99.1) (Nov 9, 2026) and U.S. SEC: Blink Charging Co. Q3 2026 Financial Results (Exhibit 99.1) (Nov 5, 2026).

1 practice question and sample answer

Say your answer out loud first, then read the sample answer.

Practice question

  1. Your client is Talbot Trucks, a leading European private truck manufacturer. The CEO wants to know what information we should collect to determine whether producing and selling electric trucks (eTrucks) in Europe is an attractive investment. How would you structure your approach?

    Sample answer. Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. To help the CEO decide whether to invest in European eTruck manufacturing, I would collect data across four areas: customer demand by segment, customer total cost of ownership, Talbot's manufacturing economics, and the European charging and regulatory environment. First, on demand, Talbot serves two distinct segments: large fleets owning thousands of trucks and smaller owner-operators. I would size annual replacement volume for each and check their route lengths, since short regional routes are much easier to electrify than long-haul routes. Second, on total cost of ownership, I would compare the €100,000 diesel truck price and fuel, maintenance, and toll costs against the eTruck's battery cost, electricity savings, and the cost of slower charging, especially given the current driver shortage where waiting at a charger wastes scarce driver hours. Third, on Talbot's economics, I would examine upfront CapEx to retool lines for e-motors and batteries, battery pack sourcing costs, and break-even volume. Fourth, on the European ecosystem, I would check public high-power truck charging density and zero-emission toll or tax exemptions. I would start with the customer TCO comparison, because if the math does not beat or match diesel for at least one route segment, demand will not scale.

    It names four clear, specific branches built for a commercial truck OEM rather than reciting a generic framework, separates the two customer segments from the prompt, brings in the operational friction of slow charging during a driver shortage, and states exactly where to start and why.

Practice the case interview, out loud

Soreno's AI interviewer runs a full case one question at a time, checks your math and scores your structure, any time you have 30 minutes.

Questions people ask

What is the Talbot Trucks McKinsey case?

Talbot Trucks is an official practice case on McKinsey's careers website where a European private truck manufacturer evaluates investing in electric trucks (eTrucks) to reduce its fleet's carbon footprint. Candidates structure the European market investigation, compare total cost of ownership (TCO) against a €100,000 diesel truck with zero residual value during a driver shortage, and calculate the maximum eTruck price that keeps TCO equal.

How do you calculate Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) in an EV case interview?

Add the upfront purchase price (minus any residual value) to lifetime operating costs: fuel or electricity, maintenance, driver wages (including extra time spent at slower chargers), insurance, tolls, and taxes. To find the maximum price an EV maker can charge, set the EV's lifetime TCO equal to the combustion vehicle's TCO and subtract the EV's lifetime operating costs.

What are the main growth levers for an electric vehicle manufacturer?

Based on BCG's automotive overview and Tesla's 2025 Form 10-K, the primary levers are lowering customer TCO through manufacturing scale and structural battery integration, alleviating charge anxiety (such as the Ford Power Promise and NACS Supercharger access), monetizing software subscriptions and autonomous ride-hailing (FSD Supervised and Robotaxi), using AI for micro-market pricing, and scaling energy storage like Powerwall and Megapack.

Can I use a calculator or AI during an EV case interview?

No. McKinsey states that calculators and real-time AI tools are not allowed during interviews or assessments, and candidates should write out calculations on paper while talking the interviewer through each step. However, McKinsey encourages using AI tools beforehand to practice interview questions and explain frameworks.

What regulatory risks should I mention in an EV growth case?

Highlight the repeal or phase-out of government subsidies, such as the One Big Beautiful Bill Act of 2025 that addresses the termination of the 30C Alternative Fuel Vehicle Refueling Property Credit, alongside import tariffs, escalating trade wars, utility permitting delays for fast chargers, and autonomous driving regulations.

Keep going