Case Interview Basics: How the Problem-Solving Interview Works

A case interview is a structured conversation where you work through a realistic client business problem step by step: you structure your approach, ask questions, analyze data, do paper calculations without a calculator, and make a recommendation. McKinsey, BCG, and Bain all state on their careers pages that there is not a single right answer and that interviewers judge how you structure the problem and the quality of your reasoning rather than memorized frameworks. You can practice a case free, no sign-up, or read the full breakdown and worked example below.

Updated

What a case interview is and where it shows up

Bain defines a case interview as a structured conversation where you work through a real business problem of the kind its teams tackle every day, and notes that case interviews are used for consulting roles only. BCG calls the same stage a case study interview or problem-solving interview, and McKinsey calls it the Problem-Solving Interview.

Across all three firms, the interview is a two-way conversation rather than an oral exam. You hear a short scenario about a client, and your job is to break the problem down, test ideas against the data the interviewer shares, and talk through your logic out loud.

If you are applying for a client-facing consulting role, the case does not happen in isolation. At McKinsey, most client-facing candidates complete the gamified Solve assessment, then pair Problem-Solving Interviews with Personal Experience Interviews (PEI) and, for some roles, an expertise interview. You can prepare for this format in a McKinsey case interview. At Bain, the consulting process typically starts with a digital assessment followed by case interviews, alongside behavioral interviews or behavioral questions that ask you to reflect on past experiences. You can practice this structure in a Bain case interview. At BCG, the global consulting sequence is an application, a skills interview, a case interview, and a team interview. Candidates rehearse this dialogue in a BCG case interview. In BCG's Switzerland office, for example, full-time graduate applicants start with a 30-minute multiple-choice cognitive test taken without tools about one month before the first interview. That is followed by a 45-minute virtual first-round case interview. The final round consists of three in-person case interviews in Zurich.

How McKinsey, BCG, and Bain describe the consulting case interview on their official careers pages

How McKinsey, BCG, and Bain describe the consulting case interview on their official careers pages
FirmOfficial name for the casePre-interview assessmentWhat the firm says it looks forPublished sample cases on its site
McKinseyProblem-Solving Interview (or case interview)Solve (gamified problem-solving assessment)How you structure tough, ambiguous challenges, identify important issues, deal with facts and data, formulate conclusions, and share tailored solutions vs. standard frameworks5 cases: Beautify, Diconsa, Electro-Light, Transforming a national education system, Talbot Trucks
BCGCase study interview (or problem-solving interview)Varies by office (e.g., 30-minute virtual cognitive test in Switzerland)Clear communication, logical thinking, business intuition, creativity, and analysis over memorized solutionsOneDay@BCG free job simulation (plus an online case library and prep calls for invited candidates in offices like Switzerland)
BainCase interviewDigital assessmentHow you think, structure problems, and build on ideas as the conversation evolves, with precision and creativity2 cases: Coffee Shop Co. and FashionCo. (plus links to Management Consulted, Crafting Cases, CaseCoach, and RocketBlocks)

The 5 steps of a case interview, in order

BCG and McKinsey lay out the core sequence clearly on their preparation pages. BCG says your task is to structure your approach, ask thoughtful questions, analyze data, perform quick calculations, and identify the most important factors. McKinsey says its goal is to see how you structure ambiguous challenges, identify important issues, deal with the implications of facts and data, and formulate conclusions and recommendations.

In a live interview, those expectations turn into five concrete steps you execute out loud. Whether you are preparing with our consulting case study examples or a firm's own sample page, every case follows this spine.

  • 1. Listen to the prompt and write down the core facts. In its Beautify practice case, McKinsey's first hint is to write down important information and ask the interviewer to explain anything that is not clear to you.
  • 2. Clarify the objective and your assumptions. BCG explicitly lists 'Clarify Assumptions' and 'Listen Actively' under its core Do's. Before you jump into branches, make sure you and the interviewer agree on what the client is trying to decide.
  • 3. Build a custom structure, not a memorized framework. McKinsey warns candidates that there is not one logical solution, so you should listen carefully and share tailored solutions rather than standard frameworks. BCG Switzerland gives the same rule: 'We value analysis over memorized solutions.' Break the client's specific question into three or four logical buckets that belong to that business.
  • 4. Work the math on paper and read the data for non-obvious trends. When the interviewer gives you numbers or an exhibit, take a breath. McKinsey's Beautify case reminds you that calculators are not allowed, tells you to write your calculations on paper, and asks you to talk your interviewer through your steps so they can see your organized approach and help you if needed. When looking at a table or chart, McKinsey advises you to note your observations and challenge yourself to identify trends that are not immediately obvious from the data.
  • 5. Formulate a clear conclusion and recommendation. Tie your numbers and observations back to the client's original question, state what you recommend the client do next, and explain the reasoning behind it.

Why standard frameworks fail (and how to build a custom structure)

Do not rely on memorized lists of named frameworks. Every major firm tells you not to rely on them. McKinsey says to share tailored solutions versus standard frameworks. Bain says it will never ask you to memorize and recite material because it is more interested in knowing how you think. BCG says it values analysis over memorized solutions.

A custom structure still uses clean logic, such as splitting profit into incremental revenue and upfront plus ongoing costs, or grouping a workforce transition into operational, financial, and customer factors. The difference is that every branch names the actual mechanism in the client's business.

For example, in McKinsey's Beautify case, the client is a prestige cosmetics company whose in-store department store beauty consultants are facing empty stores as shoppers move online. Question 1 asks what factors Beautify should consider when shifting those in-store consultants to become virtual social-media beauty advisors selling on beautify.com and social platforms. If you recite a generic framework, you sound rehearsed. If you build a structure for this client, your branches speak directly to beauty consultants, luxury shoppers, and department store channels. First is customer response, testing whether high-touch department store shoppers will buy cosmetics virtually or defect to rival counter brands. Second is consultant capabilities and economics, testing whether current store staff have social media skills, and reviewing how training and compensation work across independent country brands. Third is channel and brand impact, considering how prestige positioning and retail partner relationships with stores like Harrods or Sephora change.

How case math and exhibits work: a worked example from McKinsey's Beautify case

Quantitative questions test whether you can set up an equation cleanly on paper, calculate without a calculator, and explain each step aloud. Below is the exact math prompt from Question 3 of McKinsey's official Beautify practice case, followed by our team's step-by-step worked calculation of those numbers so you can see how to lay it out on paper and talk through it.

In Question 3 of McKinsey's Beautify case, the team wants to know how many years it will take until the virtual-advisor investment turns profitable (defined in the prompt as when incremental revenues are greater than the cost of the project). McKinsey gives you five facts: Beautify's current revenues are €1.3 billion. Virtual advisors are expected to bring a 10% overall increase in incremental revenue starting in the first year. First-year upfront investments are €50 million in IT, €25 million in training, €50 million in remodeling department store counters, and €25 million in inventory. The €50 million upfront IT investment has a 5% annual depreciation (loss in value) each year. All-in yearly ongoing costs for the shift are €10 million starting in the first year.

Here is how to work those numbers step by step on paper, labeled as our calculation from McKinsey's Beautify case data:

  • Step 1: Calculate annual incremental revenue. Beautify's baseline revenue is €1.3 billion (€1,300 million). A 10% increase gives €130 million in incremental revenue in Year 1 (and €130 million per year if sustained).
  • Step 2: Sum the Year 1 upfront investment costs. Add €50 million (IT) + €25 million (training) + €50 million (remodeling counters) + €25 million (inventory) = €150 million in upfront outlays.
  • Step 3: Add the ongoing annual costs and check IT depreciation. Ongoing yearly cost is €10 million starting in Year 1. A 5% annual depreciation on the €50 million IT investment equals €2.5 million per year. (In a live interview, you should clarify with your interviewer whether they want to count the €50 million IT spend as a full Year 1 cash outflow or include the €2.5 million annual depreciation in yearly operating costs, so you do not double-count.)
  • Step 4: Compare Year 1 incremental revenue to Year 1 total cost. On a cash-outlay basis, Year 1 total cost is €150 million upfront + €10 million ongoing = €160 million (or €162.5 million if the €2.5 million depreciation line is added separately). Against €130 million of Year 1 incremental revenue, Year 1 is net negative by €30 million (or €32.5 million). The project does not pay back in Year 1.
  • Step 5: Check Year 2 cumulative payback. In Year 2, another €130 million of incremental revenue brings cumulative incremental revenue to €260 million, while adding Year 2 ongoing costs of €10 million (plus €2.5 million IT depreciation if counted) brings cumulative costs to €170 million (or €175 million). By our calculation from McKinsey's Beautify prompt data, cumulative incremental revenue exceeds cumulative cost during Year 2 (specifically, covering the remaining €30 million to €32.5 million gap against €120 million in net Year 2 cash inflow takes roughly 0.25 to 0.28 of Year 2, so the project turns profitable early in the second year).

What to do and what to avoid during the conversation

How you carry yourself during the problem-solving conversation matters as much as your arithmetic. BCG publishes an explicit list of Do's and Don'ts on its case interview preparation page, and McKinsey adds specific rules for virtual interviews and AI use.

Use this checklist from the firms' official guidance to audit yourself during every practice run.

  • Do listen actively and clarify assumptions (BCG). If a question is not clear, McKinsey advises you to speak up and ask your interviewer to repeat it.
  • Do think structurally and show your thinking (BCG). McKinsey notes in its Beautify case that the more you talk through your steps, the easier it is for your interviewer to help you.
  • Do be yourself and communicate clearly (BCG). Both McKinsey and Bain emphasize that they want a real conversation, not a rehearsed script.
  • Don't panic under pressure or rush your response (BCG). McKinsey's Beautify hint states: 'Don't feel rushed into performing calculations. Take your time.'
  • Don't overcomplicate solutions (BCG). Stick to the factors that actually move the client's decision.
  • Don't stay silent, ignore feedback, or interrupt (BCG). If the interviewer nudges you toward a different branch or challenges an assumption, take the cue and adapt.
  • Follow virtual and AI integrity rules (McKinsey). For virtual interviews, McKinsey advises choosing a quiet private space, using headphones, keeping a laptop charger, pen, paper, and water within reach, keeping your camera on with virtual backgrounds or blurring disabled, and disabling previously installed AI software such as note-taking tools or virtual assistants. McKinsey encourages using AI during preparation to polish your resume, practice interview questions, or explain concepts and frameworks, and forbids using AI during assessments or to generate real-time answers during an interview.
How the behavioral half of the interview fits in

In all your case prep, do not forget that consulting interviews pair the case with behavioral questions. As BCG alumna Nandini Agrawal notes on BCG's interview process page, BCG interviews include a behavioral portion where you should relate your answers back to the requirements of the job. BCG also looks for five traits across its process: Integrity, Intellectual Curiosity, Creative Thinking, Collaborative Mindset, and Drive.

At McKinsey, the Personal Experience Interview (PEI) is a dedicated part of the interview for most client-facing roles. McKinsey looks for four qualities across its interviews: Personal Impact, Entrepreneurial Drive, Inclusive Leadership, and Problem Solving Skills. To prepare for the PEI, McKinsey suggests preparing two detailed personal examples for each area, focusing on your specific role, the details of the challenge, and leading with your reasoning rather than just listing actions.

At Bain, the firm states that it provides all candidates the same questions for each role to reduce bias, and asks you to come ready to speak to your CV, know your interviewers, be familiar with Bain's operating principles, and write out your questions for the interviewer ahead of time. You can rehearse these alongside your cases using our behavioral interview practice.

Where to find official practice cases and how to rehearse out loud

Avoid reading cases silently on a screen. McKinsey explicitly notes on its interviewing page that many candidates find it helpful to practice aloud with family or friends, and encourages using AI responsibly to practice interview questions and explain frameworks before your interview.

Start with the free sample cases and simulations published directly by the firms, then combine them with structured drills and live out-loud mocks:

  • McKinsey's 5 official practice cases: Beautify (cosmetics virtual advisors), Diconsa (rural financial services in Mexico for the Gates Foundation), Electro-Light (reduced-sugar sports drink launch), Transforming a national education system, and Talbot Trucks (electric trucks investment in Europe).
  • Bain's 2 official practice cases and external links: Coffee Shop Co. (whether a friend should open a coffee shop) and FashionCo. (declining revenues over five years in the fashion market). Bain also points candidates to external resources from Management Consulted, Crafting Cases (a 7-day course), CaseCoach, and RocketBlocks (beginner cases in food and beverage market entry and public sector growth, plus an intermediate market sizing case in travel and tourism).
  • BCG's simulation and library: OneDay@BCG, a free job simulation on BCG's case prep page, plus BCG's online case library and prep calls for candidates invited to interview.
  • Our 4-step out-loud rehearsal plan (written by our team): Step 1: Pick one official prompt above, set a 2-minute timer, and speak your clarifying questions and custom structure out loud before clicking 'Reveal Answer'. Step 2: Work the quantitative prompt by hand on blank paper without a calculator while narrating every equation aloud. Step 3: Deliver a 60-second spoken recommendation that starts with your answer, cites the number you calculated, and names one risk and next step. Step 4: Practice a case free, no sign-up with Soreno's voice AI interviewer to get follow-up questions in real time and see a real sample report that quotes and scores your spoken words.

From McKinsey & Company: Interviewing at McKinsey, McKinsey & Company: Beautify Practice Case, McKinsey & Company: Interview Tips & Qualities, BCG Careers: Case Interview Preparation, BCG Careers: Consulting Interview Process, BCG Switzerland: Application and Interviews, Bain & Company: Case Interview Preparation, Bain & Company: Interviewing and Bain & Company: What to Expect.

1 practice question and sample answer

Say your answer out loud first, then read the sample answer.

Practice question

  1. From Question 1 of McKinsey's official Beautify practice case: Beautify is a global prestige cosmetics company whose products are sold mainly in high-end department stores (such as Harrods and Shanghai No. 1) and online with specialty retailers like Sephora. As consumers shift online, Beautify wants to train the majority of its in-store beauty consultants to become virtual social-media beauty advisors who sell through their own pages on beautify.com, make retail appearances, and engage clients on social platforms. What factors should Beautify consider when shifting this group of employees toward these new responsibilities?

    Sample answer. Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. "To help Beautify's president and COO evaluate whether shifting in-store beauty consultants to virtual advisors will be profitable, I would structure the decision into three areas: first, Customer adoption and revenue impact. We need to know how many current high-touch department store shoppers will follow their consultant online versus walk away to rival counter brands, and how much new spending we can win from online-first shoppers across makeup, fragrance, and skin care. Second, Consultant capabilities and operating model. Right now, consultants are recruited directly or via third-party agencies and managed independently by each brand in each country. We should look at what share of current staff have the digital and social-media skills to sell on beautify.com, what the training and IT tools will cost, and how commission and brand alignment change when a consultant sells virtually. Third, Retail partner and brand equity risks. Beautify relies on prestige department stores and specialty sites like Sephora, so we should check whether moving sales to beautify.com creates channel conflict or dilutes our luxury image. I would start by sizing the incremental revenue against the training and IT costs."

    It follows McKinsey's and BCG's official guidance: it avoids reciting a generic framework, builds three custom buckets using the exact facts from the Beautify prompt (department store shoppers, decentralized brand-by-country consultant management, and retail partners like Harrods and Sephora), and ends by proposing a concrete first step.

Practice the case interview, out loud

Soreno's AI interviewer runs a full case one question at a time, checks your math and scores your structure, any time you have 30 minutes.

Questions people ask

What is a case interview in simple terms?

Bain defines a case interview as a structured conversation where you work through a real business problem of the kind consulting teams tackle every day. BCG calls it a problem-solving interview where you structure an approach, ask questions, analyze data, perform quick calculations, and identify the most important factors.

Is there a single right answer in a case interview?

No. McKinsey, BCG, and Bain all state on their official preparation pages that there is not a single right answer. Interviewers evaluate how you structure the problem, the quality of your reasoning, and how you build on ideas as the conversation evolves.

Should I memorize standard business frameworks for a case interview?

No. McKinsey explicitly advises candidates to listen carefully and share tailored solutions rather than standard frameworks, BCG states that it values analysis over memorized solutions, and Bain notes that it will never ask you to memorize and recite material.

Are calculators allowed in a consulting case interview?

No. McKinsey's official Beautify practice case states that calculators are not allowed and recommends writing out your calculations on paper while talking your interviewer through your steps.

Can I use AI to prepare for a case interview?

Yes, for preparation only. McKinsey's official hiring guidance encourages using AI to practice interview questions, polish your resume, and explain concepts or frameworks during prep, while strictly prohibiting AI use during assessments or to generate real-time answers during a live interview.

Keep going