Case study interview: what it is, with an example

A case study interview is a job interview where you get a business problem and work through it out loud, or in a short write-up, to show how you think. You clarify the goal, structure the problem, use the data you are given, do some quick math and recommend what to do. Consulting firms use it most, and banks, tech companies and other employers run their own versions. To practice one out loud, Soreno, an AI voice interview practice app for consulting, investment banking and other finance candidates, runs case interviews with an interviewer who pushes back and scored feedback.

Updated

  • A business problem, solved in front of you. The interviewer watches how you think more than the final answer.
  • Five steps. Clarify, structure, read the data, do the math, recommend.
  • Three common formats. Live with an interviewer, online and timed, or take-home and presented.
  • Not only consulting. Banks, product teams and other employers use cases too.
  • No single right answer. McKinsey, BCG and Deloitte each say so on their careers pages.

What a case study interview is

McKinsey calls its version the problem-solving interview, sometimes referred to as a case interview: a typical client scenario that shows how you approach complex problems. BCG calls it a case study or problem-solving interview. Outside consulting the problem is closer to the job, such as a product to launch or a loan portfolio to grow, but the skills are the same.

Live case

You and an interviewer work through one problem out loud.

Who leads
The interviewer or you
Notes
Pen and paper

Online assessment

A problem-solving test on screen, alone, before the live rounds.

Examples
McKinsey's Solve game
Timing
Set by the test
Who
You alone

Take-home case

Data or a brief to work on for days, then slides you present.

Common in
Product, strategy, analytics roles
Output
A short deck or memo
Then
You present and take questions

Written case on the day

A pack of slides or data to read alone, then you present.

Reading
A set time, alone
Then
A recommendation, defended
A worked example, start to finishSoreno's invented case

FreshFold, a chain of 20 laundromats that Soreno made up for this example, is thinking about adding pickup and delivery at $15 an order. The owner asks: should we do it?

  1. 1. Clarify

    Say the goal back, then ask

    "So the question is whether delivery would make money for FreshFold, and how soon. Is there a goal, such as a payback period?" The interviewer says the owner wants the setup cost back within two years.

  2. 2. Structure

    Lay out what you need to know

    "I'd look at three things: will customers use it, what each order earns after costs, and what it costs to set up. Then the risks, such as rivals copying it."

  3. 3. Analysis

    Ask for data, say what it means

    The interviewer shares a survey: about 30 orders a week per store. Each order costs $7 of driver time and $2 of van costs. The app and vans cost $250,000. "So each order costs $9, and the survey number is the one I trust least."

  4. 4. Math

    Work it out loud

    "$15 less $9 is $6 an order. At 30 orders that is $180 a store each week, or $187,200 a year across 20 stores. $250,000 over that pays back in about 16 months. At 20 orders a week it would take about 2 years."

  5. 5. Recommend

    Answer first, then the reason and the risk

    "Yes, but start with a pilot. At the survey's volume it pays back in about 16 months, well inside two years. The risk is volume: at 20 orders a week it takes about two years, right at the owner's limit. I'd run it in 5 stores for two months, check real orders against the survey, then roll it out."

Who uses case study interviews4 fields

The same five steps, with problems that look like the job.

  1. Consulting

    McKinsey, BCG, Bain, Deloitte and more

    Most of the interview is the case, alongside questions about you. Deloitte says its cases are fictional examples of the kinds of client projects it works on.

    Case interview preparation
  2. Banking and finance

    Capital One, private equity

    Capital One runs case interviews for business analyst roles, starting with a mini case. Private equity interviews often add a deal case or a paper LBO.

    Capital One case interview
  3. Product and tech

    Product and strategy roles

    A product to design, a metric that dropped or a feature to launch. Often a take-home or a live product case.

    Product manager interview
  4. Other roles

    Marketing, operations, analytics

    Usually a take-home: a data set or a brief, then a short presentation of what you found and what you would do.

The kinds of case problem6 kinds

Each has a usual starting structure. Adapt it to the client.

  1. Profitability

    Why did profit fall?

    Split profit into revenue and costs, find which moved, then why.

    Profitability framework
  2. Market entry

    Should we enter this market?

    Is the market worth it, can the client win, would it make money, how to get in.

    Market entry framework
  3. Market sizing

    How big is it?

    Estimate a market or a count, with a clear method and a sanity check.

    Market sizing questions
  4. Pricing

    What should we charge?

    Value to the customer, cost and competitors, then a price you can defend.

  5. Deals

    Should we buy it?

    The market, the target, the fit and the price, with the deal breaker named early.

  6. Operations

    Why is it slow or costly?

    Follow the process step by step and find where it changed.

    How to build an issue tree

From McKinsey: interviewing, BCG: case interview preparation, Deloitte: case and scenario tips and Capital One: the business analyst interview.

What the interviewer is looking for

BCG, Bain and Deloitte careers pages show that interviewers look for problem-solving skills, analytical ability, logical thinking, business intuition and whether you communicate clearly.

  • Reasoning over the right answer

    BCG says there isn't always a single right answer. Deloitte doesn't expect the right answer, it wants your logic and thought process conveyed clearly.

  • A structure for this problem

    McKinsey asks candidates to listen carefully and share tailored solutions rather than standard frameworks.

  • Thinking out loud

    McKinsey calls the case a problem-solving conversation. Say what you are doing and why, so the interviewer can follow.

  • Clarity on the objective

    Bain's first tip for its case is to clarify the objective before you start.

From BCG: case interview preparation, Deloitte: case and scenario tips, McKinsey: interviewing and Bain: case interview.

12 case study interview questions to practice

Two of each common kind, in our words. Each note says what a strong answer does.

Profitability2 cases
  1. A regional grocery chain's profits are down 20% in two years. Why?

    What a strong answer does

    Revenue and costs, each split one level down, then the part you would check first and why. Practice it, see a model answer

  2. An airline carries more passengers but earns less. What is going on?

    What a strong answer does

    Check revenue per passenger and cost per seat before anything else. Practice it, see a model answer

Market entry and growth2 cases
  1. A European e-bike maker wants to enter the US. What would you need to know?

    What a strong answer does

    Market, rivals, the client's edge and the way in, ending on yes or no. Practice it, see a model answer

  2. A furniture retailer with 60 stores wants to sell online. How would you approach it?

    What a strong answer does

    What online adds, what it takes from the stores, and what it costs to run. Practice it, see a model answer

Pricing2 cases
  1. How would you price a new drug?

    What a strong answer does

    The value to patients and payers, the alternatives and the cost, then a range, not one number. Practice it, see a model answer

  2. Should an airline raise its checked-bag fee?

    What a strong answer does

    Extra revenue per bag against travelers who switch airlines or pack lighter. Practice it, see a model answer

Investments and deals2 cases
  1. Should a manufacturer build a second factory?

    What a strong answer does

    Demand it would serve, the cost and payback, and cheaper ways to add capacity. Practice it, see a model answer

  2. Two regional airlines want to merge. How large are the savings?

    What a strong answer does

    Name the kinds of synergy, size the two biggest and say what could delay them. Practice it, see a model answer

Operations2 cases
  1. On-time delivery fell from 95% to 80%. How would you find out why?

    What a strong answer does

    Map the steps from order to delivery and find where the delays start. Practice it, see a model answer

  2. Should a carmaker keep making a key part or buy it from a supplier?

    What a strong answer does

    Cost, quality, control and risk, compared side by side. Practice it, see a model answer

Market sizing2 cases
  1. How many diapers are used in the US each year?

    What a strong answer does

    Babies by age, diapers per day, round as you go, then check the total. Practice it, see a model answer

  2. Estimate the annual revenue of one movie theater.

    What a strong answer does

    Screens, shows, seats filled and spend per visit, including food. Practice it, see a model answer

Mistakes and how to prepare

Where candidates slip
  • Starting before the goal is clear

    Say the question back and ask what success looks like. A payback target or a growth goal changes the whole answer.

  • A framework that fits any company

    Interviewers notice. Build the branches from this client's question.

  • Numbers with no meaning

    After every calculation, say what it means for the decision.

  • No answer at the end

    Say yes or no first, then the reasons and the main risk. A recommendation with a test or pilot is still an answer.

  • A take-home that is too long

    A few slides with one clear recommendation beats a long appendix. Lead with the answer.

How to prepare for a case study interview

Our suggested order, for any field.

  1. First

    Learn the five steps on one example

    Work the FreshFold case above yourself, then the free sample case, out loud.

    Free sample case

  2. Daily

    Ten minutes of math by hand

    Percentages, margins and payback, said out loud, until they no longer slow you down.

    Free case math drills

  3. Weekly

    Full cases with someone who pushes back

    A partner or an AI interviewer who asks follow-ups. Mix the six kinds of problem.

    Case interview questionsConsulting case study examples

  4. Before the day

    Read the employer's own pages

    Many publish sample cases and tips, such as McKinsey's five sample cases and Deloitte's case prep tools.

    Consulting firm interview guides

Practice a case study interview, out loud

Soreno's AI interviewer gives you a case, asks follow-ups, shows exhibits, checks your math and scores the session. Start your free week.

Questions people ask

What is a case study interview?

A job interview where you get a business problem and work through it out loud, or in a short write-up, to show how you think: clarify the goal, structure the problem, use the data, do quick math and recommend what to do.

Is a case study interview the same as a case interview?

Yes. Consulting firms usually say case interview, and McKinsey calls its version the problem-solving interview. Employers outside consulting more often say case study.

How long is a case study interview?

The employer sets it, and your recruiter tells you. Capital One, for one, starts business analyst interviews with a mini case, then more interviews on a virtual Power Day. A take-home can give you a few days.

How do you answer a case study interview question?

Clarify the goal, lay out three or four things you need to know, ask for data and say what it means, do the math out loud, and end with a recommendation, a reason and a risk.

What is a take-home case study interview?

A brief or a data set to work on alone, often over a few days, then a short presentation of your answer with questions from the panel. It is common for product, strategy and analytics roles.

Can I use a calculator?

In a live consulting case, usually not. McKinsey's careers FAQ says calculators are not allowed in its interviews. In a take-home you use whatever tools you like unless told otherwise.

Keep going